Independent exact certification of machine-generated mathematics — exact arithmetic, no code shared with the claimant, refusal as a verdict. You can disagree with a result on this site by running something, and the disagreement is then about the mathematics rather than about which of us is more credible.
the job
Narrow, and not solving
Take a numerical claim someone already believes — from a language model, from a published paper, or from my own draft — and either produce an interval that provably contains the true answer, together with the program that produced it, or report that the method did not reach one and stop there.
Much of the recent work is verification of machine-generated mathematics: AI-claimed results re-checked in independent arithmetic, each check first shown to fail on a deliberately broken copy of itself. The tools are interval arithmetic with outward rounding, exact rational arithmetic — BigInt on one side, standard-library fractions on the other — Sturm chains, and contraction arguments of the Krawczyk kind.
I work alone, from Brazil.
three lines of work
What the reports decide
Audits of machine-generated mathematics (47). Claims produced by AI systems and autonomous discovery platforms — releases, registries, manuscripts, announced records — re-decided from their published bytes, by programs that share no code with the claimant. The series.
Evaluation whose ground truth is a proof (10). Graders measured against provably wrong answers, answer keys re-decided, and environments and benchmarks in which a certificate replaces the answer key. The series.
Theorems and exact values (28) and certified decisions for operations (10). Results proved here in exact rational or outward-rounded interval arithmetic — the calibration of the instruments, and some values that were not known. Engineering and operational numbers decided over declared envelopes: aviation, maritime, energy, ocean statistics. Each page names what it does not claim. Theorems · decisions.
the standard
Three things every page here owes you
The program, not a description of it. Every page is generated from the records it cites, and the repository — engine, instruments, certificates, corpus — is public under MIT with no dependencies. The detached verifiers run in the Python standard library: the next person to extend one needs neither my permission nor my machine.
Proof that the check can fail. A check that has never gone red is decorative — consistent with the code being right, and equally consistent with the check testing nothing. So every battery carries red controls, deliberate forgeries that must be caught, and every instrument is calibrated against a case with a known answer before it decides anything new.
The errors, dated, in public. Refuted claims are published with their generating mechanism named, and the machine’s own defects are recorded the same way. Every real bug this project has found was caught by a control, a calibration, an impossible number or a byte pin — or, since 2026-10-09, by an adversarial read of the code, counted apart; the erratum of that date is on the machine page. Since 2026-10-24, outside reruns have found defects too — three in one reading by maximusrufus, none moving a verdict (below).
what that does and does not buy
None of it makes the work correct. It makes it checkable, which is a weaker property and a more useful one.
outside the building
Where the work has gone, and what has come back
Credited elsewhere: what registries, claimants, columnists and curated lists have published about this work, each quoted from a snapshot pinned by sha256 (corpus/recognition.json).
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-18. The optimization-constants registry (D. Davis, P. Ivanisvili, T. Tao): Three asterisks removed on our replays — C₃b, C₃c and C₇₁ — merged by T. Tao (pull request #216); the constants' pages cite the replays as [T2026]. In their words: “with no code shared with the claimants, by C. Toledo” (the source, pinned)
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-18. The optimization-constants registry (D. Davis, P. Ivanisvili, T. Tao): A fourth asterisk removed — C₃c's two-law certificate — on our replay, merged by T. Tao (pull request #230). In their words: “by C. Toledo, 17 Oct 2026; asterisk removed.” (the source, pinned)
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-18. The optimization-constants registry, constant 3b: The constant's page lists the replay as a reference of its own. In their words: “[T2026] Toledo, Carlos. Independent replay of the 13-point [MI2026] certificate” (the source, pinned)
Credited by the claimant, 2026-10-24. The Qiushi Engine authors (Oxelra-AI): The claimants credit the complete verification of all nineteen kissing configurations in their English and Chinese READMEs, linking the report and the programs. In their words: “Carlos Toledo has independently verified the complete configurations in all 19 dimensions, confirming their point counts and exact dimensions.” (the source, pinned)
Credited by the claimant, 2026-10-24. The Qiushi Engine authors (Oxelra-AI), Chinese README: The same credit in the Chinese README. In their words: “Carlos Toledo 已对 全部19个维数的完整构型完成独立验证” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-10-23. Maximusrufus, an independent replayer of AI-generated mathematics: Opening cert-machine issue 1, before re-running three of our records and finding no disagreement. In their words: “It covers much of the same ground, carefully, and I will cite it in our related-work notes.” (the source, pinned)
Written about in a column, 2026-10-29. Reg Saddler's column The Build (@zaibatsu on X): The column led with the replay of both labs' ETH proofs, and printed a correction: the outside check it had called missing had been done. In their words: “A Researcher in Brazil Replayed OpenAI's and Anthropic's Complexity Proofs” (the source, pinned)
Listed, 2026-10-26. Whataifound.org, a public tracker of what AI systems have found: Its entry on OpenAI's math release cites the kernel audit and the statement readings, and its no-outside-checks assessment was corrected on them. In their words: “Dated the initial no-outside-checks assessment and added MathVet and Carlos Toledo's cert-machine reports at their recorded OpenAI revisions” (the source, pinned)
Listed, 2026-10-17. Awesome-ai-proofs (a registry of AI-assisted mathematical results): Two of our audits recorded as audit events: the 4 × 4 matrix-multiplication decompositions (the row now marked verified) and the HorizonMath diagonal-Ramsey certificate (marked disputed). In their words: “Audit events from cert-machine (https://github.com/carlostoledo1891/cert-machine).” (the source, pinned)
Listed, 2026-10-06. Awesome-AI-Scientist (a curated list): cert-machine listed under peer review and verification. In their words: “cert-machine, Independent exact certification of machine-generated mathematics” (the source, pinned)
Listed, 2026-10-07. Plasma-ai/erdos, an open record of the Erdős problems: The δ₃ = 117/2192 result recorded as a claim on Problem 1186 (status: claimed), with the paper, the page and the archive. In their words: “title: Toledo's computer-assisted value of delta_3” (the source, pinned)
Listed, 2026-10-06. Erdosproblems.com, Problem 1186: Listed as a partial proof claim; the site says a listing is no guarantee of correctness and that nobody there has examined the proof. In their words: “claimed by Carlos Toledo (using Claude (Anthropic)).” (the source, pinned)
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-26. The optimization-constants registry (D. Davis, P. Ivanisvili, T. Tao): C₈₄b corrected on our check: the row now records the note's theorem, 1.9993*, instead of its "suggested" 0.000719; merged by T. Tao (pull request #257), and the page cites the check as [T2026]. In their words: “[T2026] Toledo, Carlos. Interval-arithmetic check of the [Al26] chain” (the source, pinned)
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-26. The optimization-constants registry (D. Davis, P. Ivanisvili, T. Tao): Four more asterisks removed on our replay — the C₁a and C₁b step-function rows (Atris; EinsteinArena's AgentDiscover and CodexProLong) — merged by T. Tao (pull request #232) minutes after he stated the second-party rule; the two pages cite the replay as [T2026b]. In their words: “by C. Toledo, 18 Oct 2026; asterisks removed.” (the source, pinned)
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-26. The optimization-constants registry (D. Davis, P. Ivanisvili, T. Tao): Two more asterisks removed on our replay — C₁c and C₁d — merged by T. Tao (pull request #243), the C₁d bound now printed rounded up, above the value first printed; the two pages cite the replay as [T2026]. In their words: “by C. Toledo, 20 Oct 2026; asterisks removed, and the $C\_{1d}$ bound printed rounded up” (the source, pinned)
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-26. The optimization-constants registry, constants 1a and 1b: The constants' pages list the replay as a reference of their own. In their words: “[T2026b] Toledo, Carlos. Independent replay of the [A2026] and [EA2026] step functions for $C\_{1a}$ and $C\_{1b}$” (the source, pinned)
Cited by a registry, 2026-10-26. The optimization-constants registry, constants 1c and 1d: The constants' pages list the replay as a reference of their own. In their words: “[T2026] Toledo, Carlos. Independent replay of the step-function certificates for $C\_{1c}$ [R2026] and $C\_{1d}$ [CERT2026]” (the source, pinned)
Written about in a column, 2026-10-31. Giulio Prisco's newsletter Metafuturing week (@giulioprisco on X, an X article): The weekly column's item on the two ETH refutations cites the replay of both labs' Lean proofs on two kernels, and quotes the page's limit that a kernel cannot say what a statement means. In their words: “Carlos Toledo replayed both labs' Lean proofs on two independent kernels and found that both check against their own statements.” (the source, pinned)
Written about in a column, 2026-11-04. N365 ETH Watch, the Novelty ThreeSixtyFive newsletter on Substack: The explainer on whether the two ETH refutations reach the textbook ETH reads both labs' Lean statements, cites the replay on two kernels and the bridge proofs, and quotes the e-mail on what would move the verdict to certified. In their words: “We asked Carlos Toledo, who independently re-checked both labs’ proofs, to explain his result.” (the source, pinned)
Credited by the claimant, 2026-11-06. JeetuSK0808 on GitHub, author of the C₈₉b and C₈₉c Ramsey-multiplicity certificates in the optimization-constants registry: Thanked the two independent exact replays of his K₅ and K₆ certificates (ours of 27 October, then arhancanli's), corrected his page row after our note on the descent, and now states the bounds as self-hosted and independently replayed in the pull-request threads (#277, #279). In their words: “Thank you both for the replays, and for taking the time to write them up so carefully.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-07. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed exactly, with their own code and no program of either repository, the two C₈₉a step-graphon rows added in #255; the [SK2026] fraction they reached is the one our replay reached. In their words: “carlostoledo1891's replay above reaches the same [SK2026] fraction.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-07. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code, the [R2026] and [CERT2026] certificates whose asterisks our pull request #243 removed: both fractions as the pages state, and the starred C₁d row, as printed, not an upper bound, as our replay [T2026] found. In their words: “This agrees with [T2026]'s replay.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-07. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code, the [A2026] row whose asterisk our pull request #232 removed: the exact fraction, below the printed bound, as our replay [T2026b] found. In their words: “This agrees with [T2026b]'s replay.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-08. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code, the other three C₁a and C₁b rows whose asterisks our pull request #232 removed ([EA2026]'s 1a row, [A2026]'s and [EA2026]'s 1b rows): each bound holds, by the values our replay [T2026b] found. In their words: “All three agree with [T2026b]'s values.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-08. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code, the C₁₆ upper bound of maximusrufus's #246, which our second-party replay had confirmed: the bound holds, its largest endpoint value 8.5·10⁻¹⁰ below the printed 2.1562256466; they name ours as the first replay by a party unconnected with the author. In their words: “As far as we can see, this is the second replay by a party unconnected with the author, after carlostoledo1891's above.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-07. HedonismJesse on GitHub (Human-AI-Evolution/weight-space-notes), commenting in the weight-space-programming authors' log repository; not one of its authors: Re-ran the post-trained model under a matched protocol (16K cap, thinking on, MATH-500 n = 50): accuracy .08 with .98 of runs hitting the cap, our C1 cell almost exactly; and added a cell with the MLP blocks reverted to the base model (.30 accuracy) that recovers part of the same looping. In their words: “reproducing your C1 cell almost exactly” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-08. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code, the 16a lower bound vidigoat's #226 added (C₁₆ ≥ 2.156224): L ≥ 2.15622475379391336305, the digits of our check of 16 October on the same pull request; their replay of the 70a row there likewise lands on our enclosure. In their words: “the same digits as the check posted above on 16 October” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-09. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Reproduced, with their own code and a red control, the ceiling our #275 prints for the 84b row (0.0007150508): with the record's three relaxations their chain gives 0.00071505073368…, which the pull request rounds up. In their words: “So this pull request's $0.0007150508$ is that value rounded up, as it says” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-09. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code, the C₃c lower bound of #221 (two digit laws in base 55): the ratio 1.674894211307116228…, agreeing with our check of 15 October on the same pull request. In their words: “the second replay after carlostoledo1891's above, and it agrees with it” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-11. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code and from the certificate data alone, the circulant certificate for R(3, 33) ≥ 241 that pull request #252 cites on the 17b page: triangle-free, and no independent 33-set in any of the 31 orbital searches, as our re-decision of 27 October on the same thread found. In their words: “It holds, in agreement with carlostoledo1891's re-decision above.” (the source, pinned)
Credited by the claimant, 2026-11-09. Cameron Freer on GitHub, author of the quartic stack (pull requests #8 to #16) in the ℤ-in-ℚ repository (elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q): Thanked our non-author review of his stack and answered its gaps one by one: the rows and tables we could not check are published in a separate evidence pull request (#23), the wording note is recorded in an errata file, and the later layers are named as outside the review. He adds that none of this extends the review’s scope or stands in for the repository’s “Protocol / independent agent audit” check. The comment says of itself, in its first line, that it was “drafted by Opus, reviewed by Astra”. In their words: “It is careful, and its scope is stated precisely. You checked the finite facts you list (T, N, A and B at the six heads). You left the row identities and the sum-of-squares expansion open because the rows were not published. That gap was ours.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-09. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code and from the certificate's data alone, the C₇₁ lower bound that pull request #130 added (an 18-variable function, C₇₁ > 6.521845710923046575): it holds, and the stated gain of exactly 1/133 over the 17-variable row is confirmed. They call theirs the second replay, after ours, which the 71a page cites as [T2026], and say the two agree. In their words: “As far as we can see this is the second replay, after Toledo's [T2026] cited on the 71a page, and the two agree.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-09. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Replayed, with their own code and from the certificate's law alone, the C₃b lower bound that pull request #92 added (the 13-point law, C₃b ≥ 1.77898884): it holds. They call theirs the second replay, after ours, which the 3b page cites as [T2026], and say the two agree. In their words: “As far as we can see this is the second replay, after Toledo's [T2026] cited on the 3b page, and the two agree.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-09. HedonismJesse on GitHub (Human-AI-Evolution/weight-space-notes), commenting in the weight-space-programming authors' log repository; not one of its authors: Used the per-sample token counts of our public record (wsp-baseline.json, the non-thinking condition C3) as the reference for another commenter's thinking-off run, without a new run: at that run's 8,192-token limit, 255 of our 500 first samples would be cut and 150 would be correct. The next day he paired his own 500 problems with the same rows. One part of that paired reading (that his generations run longer where ours were short) he withdrew a few hours later, after a defect was found in his own token counts; it is not credited here. A use of the record as a reference, not a re-run of it. In their words: “carries per-sample token counts for C3, so the length distribution under his exact settings (vLLM, temp 1.0 / top_p 1.0 / presence 2.0, official weights) is already public.” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-09. Jared Condon (buzzedaldrinx86-creator on GitHub), an outside commenter in the weight-space-programming authors' log repository: Thanked the record, then added a data point of his own: the unedited model with thinking off under the authors' own non-thinking settings, one pass over the 500 problems, 41.2% correct with 36.2% of the answers cut at an 8,192-token limit. A thank-you and a separate run, not a re-run of ours: by his own account it differs from our C3 in temperature, top_p, presence penalty, token limit and engine at once. In their words: “Thanks for this record, Carlos.” (the source, pinned)
Credited by the claimant, 2026-11-12. JeetuSK0808 on GitHub, submitter of the [SK2026] step-graphon row for C₈₉ in the optimization-constants registry: The description of his pull request #276, which proposes taking the asterisks off two C₈₉ rows, names our replay of 27 October as one of the two replays of [SK2026] by people other than its submitter (the other is arhancanli's), and says the removal for that row rests on those two replays, not on his own checks. This is the description of an open pull request as it read on 12 November 2026, and it can be edited; it is not a merge. In their words: “The [VSJ2026] and [SK2026] rows have now been replayed exactly by people other than their submitters, with separate code, in the thread of #255: A. Canli replayed both step graphons (comment, 7 Nov), and C. Toledo replayed [SK2026] (comment, 27 Oct).” (the source, pinned)
Noted by an independent replayer, 2026-11-10. Arhancanli on GitHub, an independent replayer of the optimization-constants registry's certificates (quantavane-replays), with no connection to their authors: Posted the second-party confirmation that the registry's rule asks for on pull request #276, which takes the asterisks off two C₈₉ rows: their own replay of both step graphons gives exactly the fractions the rows keep, [SK2026] among them, the row we replayed on 27 October. They state that they have no connection with the submitters or with us. The pull request was open on 14 November 2026; this is a comment, not a merge. In their words: “We have no connection with JeetuSK0808, with L. Van Seters and M. Jothimani, or with C. Toledo.” (the source, pinned)
Independently re-derived, no shared code — 30 September 2026. rainrzk (GitHub): λ(4) for Erdős #510 (reports/lambda4.html): the cubic, the 14 generic collisions and the nine families re-derived from the write-up with independent code; every finite case re-certified in interval arithmetic; every gcd-reduced 4-set with largest element ≤ 80 swept as a proof-independent control. Outcome: the same verdict; three documentation findings in the write-up, folded in (commit 1c248ca) (the audit · the thread).
Independently re-derived, no shared code — 23 October 2026. maximusrufus (GitHub): Twelve register rows re-decided with their own exact code, at cert-machine aa52e8d (Linux): the kissing configurations of AlphaEvolve (593) and EinsteinArena (594, 604); the sum–difference certificates of 3b (13 points) and 3c (147 and 95 points), agreeing to 30 digits; and six EinsteinArena constructions — two circles-in-a-rectangle (with the 44 overlapping pairs of the as-published Together AI packing), two Heilbronn convex, two min-distance ratios. A duplicated vector and moved probability weight are rejected by their check as by ours. Outcome: the same verdict on all twelve rows, no disagreement; two findings, both answered on the thread (the audit · the thread).
Re-run by a third party with the tools that wrote the record — 23 October 2026. maximusrufus (GitHub): The three ledgers re-derived with the tools that write them, at cert-machine aa52e8d (Linux, Python 3.14.4, Node v22.11.0); verify_sumdiff.py run beside the sum–difference ledger, its false-bound control firing. Outcome: every verdict and count identical (the audit · the thread).
Independently re-derived, no shared code — 24 October 2026. JeetuSK0808 (GitHub): The registry’s two C₃₁ rows (Lueker’s automaton at h = 9 and h = 10), our replay of reports/chvatal-sankoff.html re-derived with their own C program, written from Lueker’s published programs with no code of ours or the claimant’s: the state counts equal ours at h = 8, 9 and 10 (6,419,109; 51,425,006; 400,253,317); λ certified in round-to-nearest with an explicit inflation; γ₂ ≤ 0.8251007652 and ≤ 0.8241199563, below the printed bounds. Outcome: the same verdict on both rows; their bounds a little looser (vectors stopped once certified); their independence confirmed on the thread 2026-10-27 (the audit · the thread).
Independently re-derived, no shared code — 24 October 2026. JeetuSK0808 (GitHub): The registry’s C₈₄b correction (reports/optimization-constants.html §4) re-derived in their own interval arithmetic (mpmath), the note’s lemmas and inputs taken as given: c ≈ 0.000706 at the note’s choice; at most about 0.000707 over Y and X with R_K ≤ 103^d, and 0.00071385 with the regulator at its limit — so 0.000719 is not reached and 1.9993 is the entry. Outcome: the same verdict; their 0.00071385 is the maximum, our 0.0007150508 a ceiling above it (answered on the thread, where we printed 0.0007150507: the ceiling truncated, rounded outward since 2026-10-24) (the audit · the thread).
Re-run by a third party with the tools that wrote the record — 24 October 2026. maximusrufus (GitHub): The registry’s C₄₂ record (certs/turan-ledger.json) re-derived with the tool that writes it, at cert-machine 8924797: both rows identical. The rerun’s reading of instruments/turan/c42.py found three defects, none moving a verdict: failed checks answered REFUTED where the rule asks REFUSED, printed upper ends truncated rather than rounded outward, and the two routes compared on truncated strings. Outcome: the same verdicts (PARTIAL); the three defects fixed, recorded in the self-audit’s amendment of 2026-10-24 (the audit · the thread).
Independently re-derived, no shared code — 24 October 2026. maximusrufus (GitHub): Google’s AlphaEvolve Ramsey lower-bound graphs decided with their own clique search (two methods), before ours and with no code of ours: 15 of the 18 graphs, the verdicts compared with certs/ramsey-ledger.json. Outcome: the same verdict on all 15; R(10,12) and R(7,13), which they could not finish, decided here; R(8,18) unfinished on both sides (the audit · the thread).
Independently re-derived, no shared code — 11 November 2026. arhancanli (GitHub): R(3, 33) ≥ 241, JeetuSK0808’s circulant certificate, which we re-decided on 2026-10-27 (the outside row of certs/ramsey-ledger.json): replayed with their own code from the certificate data alone, none of the deposit’s programs read or run. The file’s graph is the Cayley graph of Z₂₄₀ on a symmetric set of 32 residues (3,840 edges), triangle-free by two routes, and it has no independent 33-set: the eight multipliers fixing 0 split its 207 non-neighbours into 31 orbits, and their own bitset branch and bound closed all 31 searches (19,242,156,924 nodes, 7,262 s of CPU on one core). Three red controls: with K = 32 the search finds an independent 32-set, with ±14 removed from the set it finds an independent 33-set, and on 60 random small circulants it agrees with brute force. Outcome: the same verdict: no triangle and no independent 33-set, through the same eight multipliers and the same 31 orbits (the audit · the thread).
Everything here is self-published and self-checked, so the honest question is what happens when it leaves. The record, with the status words meant exactly: first what has come back (35 of 221), then everything else, newest first.
Answered — sent 13 November 2026. An offer to Declan Gessel on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #5297 (Erdős #488): since 2026-10-29 a formal_proof link there must be a Palomar registry entry; Carlos offers to prepare the whole entry for Gessel’s proof with Gessel as sole author (a repository with his file ported to the Lean version Palomar requires, the challenge and solution pair against the statement, the metadata), made with Claude agents and shown to him before anything is submitted; what is asked is one line of approval and that his 50-line adapter may go under Apache-2.0. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog. (google-deepmind/formal-conjectures pull request 5297). ANSWERED by Declan Gessel on 2026-11-14 00:45 UTC, in the thread: “Sure, sounds good! Thanks for putting this together, Carlos. Happy for you to proceed and look forward to seeing the repo before submission.” He answered the offer as a whole; the licence of his adapter is to be confirmed by him on the repository shown to him. Before his answer: Nothing is built before he answers. The registry’s requirements were read the same day (Lean v4.35.0-rc2 or later, the module system, a licence file, the author’s approval). The rebased pull request stays held.
Answered — sent 7 November 2026. A comment on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #7706 (Graham's conjecture re-tagged solved): a Lean proof of the PR's statement through Pálvölgyi's heptagon and OpenAI's classification, gaps first, with the formal_proof line ready to paste. The PR's author added the link within minutes (81b79068), checked the source himself and asked for a Palomar entry; our reply committed to the entry and the link swap. (GitHub, google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #7706). outreach/gh-fc7706-heptagon-2026-11-07.md, gh-fc7706-reply-2026-11-07.md; the reply #issuecomment-6712431488; the page /reports/heptagon.html.
Answered — sent 6 November 2026. The reproducibility report on Glazer et al.'s "Z is Diophantine in Q" (11/5 release and the current Lean target): the variable count and height agree; the tower bounds hold under four named premises; H2 not decidable by computation, its nine finite ingredients hold; the four finite suites (statements on 671,659 cases of mine, his case sets replayable for one); the 48 Lean modules check; claimbox's conditional Lean proof of the frozen target from eight named hypotheses, flagged as a statement change, G proved; what it does not establish; the offer of a PR only with his yes; a version note (Version 3 appeared the same day; construction/ and lean/ unchanged). First person, Claude agents disclosed. Filed with gh. (github.com/elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q, a new issue (a computation and formalization report, per its CONTRIBUTING.md)). outreach/gh-glazer-zq-reproducibility-2026-11-06.md (untracked, v4); records at cert-machine 856b1104; the page /z-in-q/. ANSWERED 2026-11-07 11:23 UTC by Glazer (issuecomment-6706187307): thanked for the original-construction report and the Version 4 follow-up, added a commit-pinned reproducibility note (docs/audit-history/issue3/README.md at 036cebe4), and closed #3 inviting the conditional Lean PR (our #5/#6, opened 2026-11-07).
Answered — sent 6 November 2026. A follow-up comment on elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q#3: the Version 4 quartic (5cb2c199, 4,973 variables) re-checked clean-room — the coefficient table as stated, Φ exactly the sum of the squares of the 4,552 published residuals, the 551-step certificate replayed from the published source to exactly those residuals by the manuscript's step rules; 13 controls; format notes (the weights line per row id, the header's SOS degree, rows stored negated, rows_sha256 unchecked); what it does not establish (thm:quartic-selected-source, the source modules, the prose step arguments read). First person, Claude disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q/issues/3, a comment). outreach/gh-glazer-zq-v4-2026-11-06.md (untracked); record certs/zq-v4.json at cert-machine 0eeac777; /z-in-q/#version-4. ANSWERED 2026-11-07 11:23 UTC by Glazer (issuecomment-6706187307): thanked for the original-construction report and the Version 4 follow-up, added a commit-pinned reproducibility note (docs/audit-history/issue3/README.md at 036cebe4), and closed #3 inviting the conditional Lean PR (our #5/#6, opened 2026-11-07).
Answered — sent 6 November 2026. nanoda v0.4.31 panics with "memory overflow" in num-bigint's pow on the public module ZInQ.ExplicitCutoffBounds (Glazer's repository at 97cec7fd), which Lean's kernel accepts; the reproduction commands; the failed minimal case explained (Lean's kernel refuses Nat.pow beyond 32-bit exponents). First person, Claude disclosed. Filed with gh. (github.com/ammkrn/nanoda_lib, a new issue (separate from #80)). outreach/gh-nanoda-pow-overflow-2026-11-06.md (untracked); certs/zq-lean-replay.json R18, certs/zq-trackb.json B8n/X4. The maintainer asked 2026-11-06 20:36 UTC what exactly the issue and the expected behaviour are; answered after a bisection (gh-nanoda-82-reply-2026-11-06).
Answered — sent 6 November 2026. The answer to the nanoda maintainer's question on #82: a bisection on a pod (each of the module's five declarations exported alone) — d, factorialBase, g0 and t accepted, only t_lt_triplePower panics; the RUST_BACKTRACE path def_eq → lazy_delta_step → try_reduce_nat → BigUint::pow; Lean's leanchecker accepts the module; the expected behaviour (decline the power above a bound, or an error instead of a panic) offered as a reading; the logs linked, the unlicensed exports not attached. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted on Carlos's word. (github.com/ammkrn/nanoda_lib/issues/82, a comment). outreach/gh-nanoda-82-reply-2026-11-06.md (untracked); facts corpus/zq/runs/nanoda-bisect-2026-11-06/ at 5191b511; tools/runpod-zq-nanoda-bisect.sh. ANSWERED 2026-11-07 23:08 UTC by the maintainer (ammkrn, issuecomment-6714268308): likely downstream of how each checker infers let expressions rather than Nat reduction (Lean's kernel throws past its threshold rather than declining); no definitive kernel spec at this level; nanoda's let inference is 'technically closer to the ideal'; he is still deciding how to approach issues of the kind 'my code relies on implicit behavior in kernel X'. Read 2026-11-08; a reply drafted (outreach/gh-nanoda-82-ammkrn-reply-2026-11-08.md), not posted.
Answered — sent 5 November 2026. A comment on complexitylib's TM ⇔ RAM issue offering two PRs before opening them: the space-bounded TM ⇒ word-RAM simulation at logarithmic word size (k-SAT, so ETH fails on the log-word RAM; #2027's proof with one step changed, Schlesinger credited) and TM2 steps in a program-independent degree; the checks; the AI and same-author disclosure. Sent on Carlos's word. (GitHub, cslib-community/complexitylib#739). outreach/gh-complexitylib-739-2026-11-05.md; the branches re-checked: corpus/eth-refutation/complexitylib-pr/recheck-2026-11-05; Samuel Schlesinger answered 2026-11-05 02:41 UTC (issuecomment-6648220712): 'happy to take the PRs … Not sure they'll fit with the library, but the agents will help you sort that out' — the PRs opened as #2509 and #2510
Merged — sent 5 November 2026. PR 1 to complexitylib after the maintainer's yes on #739: word RAMs simulate space-bounded multi-tape machines at logarithmic word size (#2027's proof with one step changed, Samuel Schlesinger credited first in the file and in the body) and k-SAT on the log-word RAM in c·⌈2^(δn)⌉·(L+1)^e + c instructions; the AI and same-author disclosure. Opened on Carlos's word. (GitHub, cslib-community/complexitylib pull request 2509). outreach/gh-complexitylib-2509-2026-11-05.md; branch wordram-space-bounded-sim f2f244cb on the fork carlostoledo1891/complexitylib, base b28df563; recheck corpus/eth-refutation/complexitylib-pr/recheck-2026-11-05; 2026-11-05 02:59 UTC: APPROVED by the maintainers' reviewer agent (reviewer-codex-edemaine, 'agent review, not human approval'), one non-blocking placement note (the positivity certificate could live in MultiTape/…/Nat/Binary.lean); CI not yet enabled by a maintainer Merged into complexitylib on 2026-11-06 (04:16 UTC) after approval, its checks green.
Merged — sent 5 November 2026. PR 2 to complexitylib: one TM2 step and the clocked run in degrees that do not depend on the program (the reusable part of C2, restated in the plain ComputableInDegree calculus); the AI and same-author disclosure. Opened on Carlos's word. (GitHub, cslib-community/complexitylib pull request 2510). outreach/gh-complexitylib-2510-2026-11-05.md; branch tm2-degree-uniform fd0985df on the fork carlostoledo1891/complexitylib, base b28df563; recheck corpus/eth-refutation/complexitylib-pr/recheck-2026-11-05; 2026-11-05 02:56 UTC: CHANGES REQUESTED by the reviewer agent (the private foldl_step duplicates Mathlib's List.foldl_const); fixed and pushed as 68b12c06 at 03:13 UTC (module + full-library build, lint-style, hygiene green; tidy-surface and changed-files not re-run on the fix); RE-APPROVED by the reviewer agent at 03:15 UTC (no remaining findings); the one-line reply posted on Carlos's word (issuecomment-6648673308) Merged into complexitylib on 2026-11-06 (04:16 UTC) after approval, its checks green.
Answered — sent 5 November 2026. Issue on ammkrn/nanoda_lib: the 0.4.17 binary bundled with Lean v4.36.0-rc2 overflows a worker thread's stack on a 2.45 GB export and reads no stack_size_bytes (RUST_MIN_STACK no help); the source at 8de7e0c4 with a 1 GiB stack accepts in 142 s. AI help disclosed. Filed on Carlos's word. (GitHub, ammkrn/nanoda_lib issue 80). the draft outreach/gh-nanoda-stack-2026-11-05.md (untracked); linked from lean4#16290 The maintainer answered 2026-11-06 20:38 UTC: the bundled build is the comparator's choice, upstream can take a newer version or match the C++ kernel's stack; thanked and closed by Carlos the same evening (#issuecomment-6695103175), followed at leanprover/lean4#16290.
Answered — sent 5 November 2026. Issue on leanprover/con-leche: 'fuel exhausted: whnfCore' (exit 3) at a theorem of a 2.45 GB export in con-leche and con-ron alike, a compiled fuel with no setting; the comparator reports the decline as a rejection (filed as lean4#16290); the ask: a fuel setting or a documented decline exit. AI help disclosed. Filed on Carlos's word. (GitHub, leanprover/con-leche issue 16). the draft outreach/gh-con-leche-fuel-2026-11-05.md (untracked); linked from lean4#16290; ANSWERED 2026-11-05 20:11 UTC by the maintainer (nomeata): 'Could you try latest master? I have made changes since it was bundled with lean.' — our follow-up the same night is the row gh-con-leche-16-master-reply-2026-11-05; CLOSED as completed by the maintainer 2026-11-06 00:01 UTC after our master runs
Answered — sent 5 November 2026. Reply on leanprover/con-leche#16 to the maintainer's 'try latest master': con-leche master (7cb7a45c, dc8ca857) and con-ron master (97eead2d) accept both exports — the 2.45 GB chain export (98,686 declarations) and OpenAI's challenge export (93,373) — with every run's flags, time and peak RSS; con-leche needs ~66 GiB at 16 workers (killed on a 64 GB machine), 51 GiB at 8; the slowest declarations; both exports public on Zenodo as a regression test. AI help disclosed. Posted on Carlos's word ('Approved all'). (GitHub, leanprover/con-leche issue 16, a comment). the text outreach/gh-con-leche-16-master-reply-2026-11-05.md (untracked); the facts certs/eth-openai-chain.json masters and the evening's three pod runs under corpus/eth-refutation/openai-chain/runs; the deposit doi:10.5281/zenodo.23991348, pinned in exports-deposit.json beside them; ANSWERED 2026-11-06 00:01 UTC by the maintainer (nomeata): 'Thanks!', and the issue CLOSED as completed by them
Answered — sent 5 November 2026. The document link for the ETH_Repository, as the 'announce your results' page asks (a separate e-mail per document): the note v0.2 (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23985003, the PDF and the report page), superseding the v0.1 link sent the same day; OpenAI's side now in the same Lean; the caveat on the judge's checker list named; the claims the laboratories', the textbook match a reading. Sent by hand from Carlos's mailbox. (e-mail to rpaturi@ucsd.edu (a submission the organizers asked for on their page; separate from the open thread that holds the question on the definition)). REPLY 2026-11-06 by e-mail, Mohan Paturi: "I approved your posts. Do I need to post any new papers in the ETH_Repository?" — answered the same day by hand (email-paturi-reply-2026-11-06: v0.3 supersedes v0.2). outreach/email-paturi-eth-repository-v02-2026-11-05.md (untracked); companion to ethdiscussion-reply-openai-chain-2026-11-05; no attachment, links only
Answered — sent 3 November 2026. The Weight-Space Programming baseline offered to the authors first: the edit decided from the bytes (two tensors, the dose 6), the pre-registered re-run of the unedited Qwen3.5-0.8B under its card's recommended settings (C1 reproduces 7.2%; C3 non-thinking 44–52% against the edit's 48.1), the six side claims decided from their logs; a 24 h window before the public summary. (RikiyaT/lm_understand-logs issue 4). outreach/wsp-authors-issue-2026-11-03.md; records certs/wsp-weights.json, wsp-regrade.json, wsp-baseline.json, wsp-side-claims.json; C2/C4 to be added to the same record. The thread reply and the X post wait for the window (the next morning, decided 14:45 UTC on 11-03). ANSWERED 2026-11-07 07:03 UTC by a third party, not the authors: HedonismJesse (Human-AI-Evolution/weight-space-notes, issuecomment-6703692933) re-ran the post-trained model under a matched protocol (16K cap, thinking on, MATH-500 n=50): .08 accuracy / .98 cap-exhausted, our C1 cell almost exactly; the base model .40 / .36; reverting the MLP blocks to base gives .30 / .58 strict-loop. Their reading: the looping is a post-training regression carried by the MLPs. Read 2026-11-08.
Answered — sent 3 November 2026. The link for the organizers' ETH repository, as the 'announce your results' page asks: three lines to Mohan Paturi naming the page comment and https://carlostoledo.co/eth/. Sent by hand from Carlos's mailbox. (e-mail to rpaturi@ucsd.edu (a submission the organizers asked for on their page)). the text is step 2 of the 11-03 plan (this session); companion to ethdiscussion-announce-2026-11-03. REPLY 11-03 14:16/14:20 BRT (within 14 minutes), Ramamohan Paturi: "Thanks, Carlos" and "Thank you for the posting." — an acknowledgement, no question; nothing to answer.
Answered — sent 3 November 2026. The reply to a newsletter writer's e-mail (N365 ETH Watch, noveltythreesixtyfive.substack.com, received 11-03 in spam) asking what would move /eth/'s 'does not certify that ETH is false' to a certification and where the bridge between the two models stands: the plain quotable answer (the two model-equivalence steps are still prose, for the labs and for us), a contract-in-two-dialects analogy, the two third-party bridges' standing (both CERTIFIED as Lean theorems; TSavo's seam read DIFFERENT, not decided; Hawkley's predicate OpenAI's own), the quoting terms (verbatim with attribution and the link; the verdict words not paraphrased). Sent by hand from Carlos's mailbox. (e-mail reply to the newsletter's own address (answering a received e-mail; the channel rule)). outreach/n365-reply-2026-11-03.md; the Substack is nine days old with no ETH post at the time; the series was announced, not yet written. ANSWERED 11-03 ~23:30 BRT: the writer sent the full explainer before publication ('Did AI really break ETH? The small print between the proof and the textbook'), quoting the four passages verbatim with the verdict words as written and the Claude disclosure; checked here against the page and the e-mail — accurate. Carlos replied by hand (~01:00 UTC 11-04): permission to publish, two corrections (attribute the quotes to the e-mail, not the page; two kernels, three replays, not three kernels), one scope note (the lab's README sentence and the no-repeated-clause condition are theirs, unchecked here). When published: a recognition row from a pinned snapshot.; 2026-11-04 14:10 UTC: the explainer PUBLISHED (its link is on the recognition row), the three answers quoted verbatim and attributed to the e-mail, 'two kernels, three replays' as corrected; snapshot pinned and recognition row n365-eth-watch-explainer (kind press)
Answered — sent 27 October 2026. The K6 Ramsey-multiplicity certificate (C₈₉c ≤ 0.7422548616·2⁻¹⁴, J. SK's Z₂¹⁰ weight-class step graphon) re-derived by two implementations sharing no code with each other or with the claimant's evaluators: the density × 2¹⁴ equals the fraction the page states, the printed bound is it rounded up; the perturbation and half-graphon controls — offered as the second party the rule asks for. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 279). certs/graphon-replay.json at d813a99b; the page /reports/optconst-queue.html#graphons — 2026-11-05 15:04 UTC: arhancanli (quantavane-replays @ f4daa1e0, c89/) posted an independent exact replay of the same certificate on the PR, two C programs written apart plus exact rationals, with brute-force self-tests and three red controls, 'no connection with the author', AI assistance disclosed: the same fraction to the digit (0.742254861593625… · 2⁻¹⁴), the printed bound held by 6.4·10⁻¹² · 2⁻¹⁴. Their comment on the PR (15:04 UTC) does not mention ours; the two replays agree exactly. JeetuSK0808 thanked both replays on #277 (2026-11-06 05:57 UTC) and corrected his page; pinned in corpus/recognition.json (jeetu-c89-replays).
Merged — sent 23 October 2026. C₈₄b (the real sum–product exponent): the registry’s 1.999281 is the “suggested” c ≈ 0.000719 of Althoefer’s note, not its theorem c ≥ 0.0007; the chain decided in interval arithmetic holds at the note’s choice (c ≈ 0.000706) and gives c ≤ 0.0007150507 for every choice of its parameters; the row becomes 1.9993*, still asterisked (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 257). drafted 2026-10-06 (outreach/github-p2a-2026-10-06.md item 7b) and held for a courtesy e-mail that the channel rule of 2026-10-23 dropped; the body now says Prof. Althoefer is welcome to supersede it; branch cut from 46dbf036, merges cleanly with #232, #242, #243 and #249 (and #235, #250, #251); evidence certs/sumproduct-ledger.json at 422b952 (re-derived identical 2026-10-23), the note’s tex pinned by sha256 and unchanged; 2026-10-23: a registry contributor who is not a maintainer (Chessing234) requested changes — the 28 May line kept 1.999281 beside the correction as if it were still the record, and the note should go at the top; the first point taken: the 28 May line corrected in place (24cf417, one 84b line), the second declined with the evidence (the section is not newest-first; #177’s own 10c correction went at the end); reply posted, description updated; 2026-10-24: JeetuSK0808 posted a separate check (mpmath): 0.000719 not reached, 1.9993 right; their 0.00071385 at the regulator limit vs our 0.0007150507 — ours a ceiling, theirs the maximum (we recomputed their chain without the grid: 0.0007139); our answer posted (issuecomment-6379669104); recorded in corpus/external-reruns.json; 2026-10-26: MERGED by T. Tao 03:50 UTC (the row 1.9993*, citing [T2026]); the ceiling's printed digit then corrected: the description edited to 0.0007150508, a comment (issuecomment-6421787433) and the one-digit follow-up PR #275
Answered — sent 23 October 2026. A reply to maximusrufus, who opened cert-machine issue 1 offering cross-checks: their from-the-text re-run of the N(6) = 3 search (the openai/math entry our audit could not re-run, no code shipped) and Manvir Jaswal’s earlier one to be noted on that entry as external re-runs, written by us; their explicit AlphaEvolve Ramsey lower-bound graphs accepted for an exact clique/independence decision of our own; our rerun kit offered for the other direction; the two items we both decided agree (C₁₆a, C₁d). (carlostoledo1891/cert-machine issue 1). the issue opened 2026-10-23 15:21 UTC; our reply the same afternoon; they answered 16:28 UTC: pin mub6-certified-rerun at 90607dd4 (its run artifacts unchanged since 7e6ed79f), the Ramsey graphs to come at a fixed commit with sha256s, and they will re-run a few claims from our rerun kit. The dated N(6) note added to the openai/math audit the same day (0b17df38); the graphs and their re-runs wait on them; our closing reply posted the same day with the link to the note (issuecomment-6371185268); 18:24 UTC the Ramsey graphs at maximusrufus/openai-math-replays 4c5524a (Google’s 18 files pinned to google-research 0d94f8c4, SHA256SUMS, their verdicts; R(7,13), R(10,12), R(8,18) not finished); 20:02 UTC a rerun report on three of our records at aa52e8d — twelve register rows re-decided with their own code, three ledgers re-derived, no disagreement — recorded in corpus/external-reruns.json, with two findings (Windows line endings, fixed by .gitattributes; mutations stop at the pin on the ledger path); 2026-10-24 02:32 UTC their three coarse mutations (a duplicated kissing row, moved sum–difference weight, a repeated Heilbronn point) and an offer of one-ulp boundary mutants for the EinsteinArena rows; our report posted 03:13 UTC (issuecomment-6379173543): the Ramsey graphs 16 of 18 CERTIFIED (R(10,12) closed in 77 min), R(7,13) resuming, R(8,18) left open; the boundary mutants accepted; 2026-10-24: the R(7,13) update posted (issuecomment-6383790070): 17 of 18 CERTIFIED, R(8,18) open; 2026-10-24 14:32 UTC their Ramsey cross-check (15 of 15 agree), seven boundary mutants and a C42 rerun note (three defects); all fixed and recorded (ba20083b) and our answer posted (issuecomment-6389814859); 2026-10-26: asked, with no obligation, for a second-party re-run of C82/C86 under the registry's new rule (issuecomment-6421798844)
Answered — sent 22 October 2026. C₃₁ (the binary Chvátal–Sankoff constant): L. Jack's two asterisked rows (Lueker's automaton at h = 9 and h = 10) independently replayed — the automaton rebuilt from Lueker's paper alone in two implementations, calibrated on his Table II, run with witness vectors of our own under directed rounding; both bounds hold; asterisks removed (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 249). filed at the claimant's own request (e-mail of 2026-10-21); evidence at cert-machine 61aae8eb (certs/lueker-replay.json); label [T2026] on 31a.md; the README's Recent-progress list also edited by our open #242/#243; 2026-10-23: approved by a registry contributor who is not a maintainer (Chessing234), “all good”; not merged; 2026-10-24: JeetuSK0808 posted a third independent replay (their own C from Lueker’s published programs): the state counts equal ours at h = 8, 9, 10, bounds a little looser; our thanks posted (issuecomment-6379668934); recorded in corpus/external-reruns.json; 2026-10-26: T. Tao changed CONTRIBUTING (removing an asterisk takes a second party: a refereed paper, a registration such as Palomar, a maintainer, or an independent confirmation in the thread) and posted the same hold note on #232, #242, #243 and #249; our reply names JeetuSK0808's in-thread C replay as the possible second party (issuecomment-6421793297); 2026-10-27 00:26 UTC: JeetuSK0808 confirmed on the thread that they have no connection to us or to the C31 authors and wrote their replay from Lueker's published programs only (issuecomment-6430610425) — the second party the new rule asks for, if the maintainer accepts it; 2026-10-27 ~03:30 UTC, our thanks POSTED (issuecomment-6433116322), naming the K5/K6 replays on #277/#279; 2026-11-04: maximusrufus's #323 table marks C31 PARTIAL (arithmetic only, the 51M/400M-state automaton runs not replayed); the PR conflicts on constants/31a.md; nothing sent
Answered — sent 20 October 2026. R. Pinho's two asterisked certificates — C₈₆ (the Schur–Siegel–Smyth trace constant, #227) and C₈₂ (the Zhang–Zagier essential minimum, #229) — and the Épi construction the C₈₂ page also asterisks, replayed by two implementations sharing no code with each other or with the claimants, offered as the evidence that removes the three asterisks, in the form pull requests 216 and 230 were accepted. One PR for both because their README lines are adjacent. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 242). evidence at cert-machine d9a3942b; merges cleanly with #232 and #243 in either order (test merges); 2026-10-26: T. Tao changed CONTRIBUTING (removing an asterisk takes a second party: a refereed paper, a registration such as Palomar, a maintainer, or an independent confirmation in the thread) and posted the same hold note on #232, #242, #243 and #249; held for a second party; asked maximusrufus to re-run C82/C86 (cert-machine#1, issuecomment-6421798844); 2026-11-04: two second-party replays landed: arhancanli re-ran Pinho's C86 row with code of their own (05:23 UTC), and maximusrufus's #323 (Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.23938911) marks C86 and C82 REPRODUCED and says our README cell would replace main's newer [Kos2026] 1.8084990*; branch rebased onto main (2ca4846; the C86 cell 1.8117251 (1.8084990*), the Kos2026 row kept) and our reply POSTED (issuecomment-6627410507), disclosing the mutual checks with maximusrufus (#246); 2026-11-04 10:38 UTC: arhancanli also replayed both C82 rows (Pinho's certificate and the Épi construction), with two notes (the Épi value a loose but valid bound; the Épi row names no commit or hash); the row now names them (286afec, BakeLab/Epi-results 97fa6a4, construction.json e85e26fa…, the bytes our replay pinned) and our thanks POSTED (issuecomment-6633371435); each of the three rows now has an independent replay in the thread
Merged — sent 20 October 2026. The C₁c and C₁d step functions replayed by two implementations sharing no code, offered to remove their asterisks; the C₁d bound is printed below its own certificate's exact value, so the PR prints it rounded up (1.4630715826075594), and corrects C₁c's printed decimal. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 243). stacked on #232 (adjacent README table rows); evidence at cert-machine d9a3942b; 2026-10-23: approved by a registry contributor who is not a maintainer (Chessing234), “all good”; not merged; 2026-10-26: T. Tao changed CONTRIBUTING (removing an asterisk takes a second party: a refereed paper, a registration such as Palomar, a maintainer, or an independent confirmation in the thread) and posted the same hold note on #232, #242, #243 and #249; then MERGED 03:53 UTC; constants/1d.md lists [CERT2026] twice (…559* and …5594); our comment asks which way (issuecomment-6421793916)
Merged — sent 18 October 2026. The two-law certificate behind C₃c ≥ 1.674894211307116 replayed by two implementations sharing no code with each other or with the claimant, offered as the evidence that removes its asterisk, in the form pull request 216 was accepted. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 230). Merged by the maintainer 3.5 hours after it was filed (2026-10-18 05:54 UTC, commit 9938edd4): the asterisk removed, the replay cited on the C₃c page as [T2026b] and in the README's recent progress, and the L2026 row's [T2026] note restored.
Merged — sent 18 October 2026. The four step functions behind the registry's new C₁a and C₁b rows (Atris; EinsteinArena's AgentDiscover and CodexProLong) replayed by two implementations sharing no code with each other or with the claimants, offered as the evidence that removes the four asterisks the maintainer put on them, in the form pull requests 216 and 230 were accepted. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 232). 2026-10-26: T. Tao changed CONTRIBUTING (removing an asterisk takes a second party: a refereed paper, a registration such as Palomar, a maintainer, or an independent confirmation in the thread) and posted the same hold note on #232, #242, #243 and #249; then MERGED 03:53 UTC with #243, minutes after the note (our comment on #243 points out the mismatch and the duplicate [CERT2026] row in constants/1d.md)
Answered — sent 15 October 2026. Three of the five bounds in a pull request decided exactly, and two left open for want of a written derivation. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 226 (two posts)). The author answered 2026-10-16 with his derivations for 16a and 70a. Both were decided here the same day, from the written derivation and with no code of his run: CERTIFIED. Our follow-up is the last post.
Answered — sent 11 October 2026. Measurements of a kernel patch on 25 real exports from OpenAI's math release, and a request for a configurable worker stack. (ammkrn/nanoda_lib issue 44). The patch it measured was merged the same day (pull request 45) and the issue closed on 2026-10-12; the comment itself has no answer.; 2026-10-12: the maintainer closed it as fixed by #45 (merged 2026-10-11); not re-measured here (no local Lean since 2026-10-20)
Answered — sent 6 October 2026. Two audit records offered to the awesome-ai-proofs registry: the exact re-check of the 4 × 4 matrix-multiplication decompositions (AlphaEvolve rank 48 holds; AlphaTensor rank 47 holds over F₂, fails over Q) and HorizonMath's diagonal-Ramsey certificate, refuted (its λ = 1 pair lies outside the theorem's region; the validator's min for max). (subroy13/awesome-ai-proofs issue 2). Answered 2026-10-17: the maintainer added both records in commit 852a8fac (data/problems/core.yaml, data/problems/carlostoledo1891.yaml; the registry's README now lists the matmul row as ⚑ verified with Claude among the models and a new diagonal-Ramsey row as self-reported · disputed) and closed the issue. Two words softened on their side: the audit event's 'debunked' became 'disputed' and the caveat's 'refuted' became 'contested', pending their source review. Our reply, saying what the record says (REFUTED by an explicit witness; 'disputed' fair until their review), posted 2026-10-17: https://github.com/subroy13/awesome-ai-proofs/issues/2#issuecomment-6235076477 The maintainer answered the same day (issuecomment-6235146613): 'disputed' stays until HorizonMath issue 10 has a comment from its authors, and the issue is to be reopened when it does. On 2026-10-17 HorizonMath issue 10 had no comment.
Merged — sent 6 October 2026. Certificates for C3b, C3c and C71 replayed independently, so the asterisk can come off under the repository's stated rule. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 216). Merged by the maintainer on 2026-10-18 (commit ad40c534): the three asterisks are gone, and each constant page (3b, 3c, 71a) cites the replay as [T2026]. The rule it applied was the maintainer's own, from #176: an independent replay removes the marker.
Answered — sent 6 October 2026. K(25) ≥ 197,580 and K(27) ≥ 201,567 checked exactly, and a request for the coordinates of the other dimensions. (Oxelra-AI/Qiushi-Engine-Kissing-Number-Research issue 1 (three posts)). The authors published every remaining configuration within days (2026-10-11 and -12). All nineteen bounds in their paper were then checked pair by pair here, every one holds, and they linked the check beside their results table.; 2026-10-24: the authors (Cherish0925) thanked us for the complete all-pairs verification of all nineteen configurations and updated their English and Chinese READMEs to acknowledge it, linking the report and the programs
Answered — sent 6 October 2026. Erdős #1186 proposed for formalization, with the δ₃ result as context. (google-deepmind/formal-conjectures issue 6882). 2026-10-20: a third party (veljjanoski) took the issue and formal-conjectures merged PR #7467 adding Erdős Problem 1186 the same day; the issue closed as completed
Answered — sent 5 October 2026. A reproducible construction failure of the legacy SandboxEnv in verifiers 0.3.1: no prime-sandboxes release it accepts can build it. (PrimeIntellect-ai/verifiers issue 2775). Closed 2026-10-09 by a maintainer: verifiers v0 was deprecated and removed, and the legacy 0.3.x line will not get a backport.
Answered — sent 3 September 2026. A request to the authors of the 604-point dimension-11 kissing configuration for their vectors, so the one NEEDS DATA row in our ledger can be decided. (vinid/einstein-arena issue 64). The ask is offer-shaped: the certification is already built and waiting on the bytes. Answered 2026-09-07: the maintainer gave the path to the vectors; the two 604-point configurations were decided congruent (a signed coordinate permutation) and the issue was closed 2026-09-08. Two later posts in the same thread: the re-run kit offered (2026-10-05), and a correction of our own figure for the best n = 841 submission, 41,128 exact contacts to 40,992 over its 840 distinct directions (2026-10-06).
Answered — sent 2 September 2026. λ(4) = −L(1,2,3,4) offered as an unusually clean Lean formalization target — six elementary lemmas, exact rational identities, and 2,231 finite cases each carrying a certified enclosure. (teorth/erdosproblems issue 392). Answered 2026-09-30: rainrzk re-certified the whole argument with independent code (erdos510-lambda4-audit), same verdict, three write-up findings folded in; our reply is the last post. 2026-11-12: the auditor’s account now shows as yuanzhu-lab on the thread and the audit is at yuanzhu-lab/erdos510-lambda4-audit on GitHub; its notes list five documentation findings, of which three were folded into the write-up.
Answered — sent 31 August 2026. The Erdős #290 square-discriminant law as exact integer identities, with a certified bracket for the Galois-density constant — and a correction to my own earlier write-up, in the same comment. (teorth/erdosproblems issue 164). Superseded on the mathematics five days later by arXiv:2609.00104, which proves the liminf exactly; our bracket is now the certified numeric value of that constant rather than one end of a range, and the page says so. Woett answered 2026-09-08 with the theorem; the follow-up with the 1/(1+c) bracket was posted 2026-10-06.
Posted, no reply — sent 14 November 2026. Our pull request #5 on the ℤ-in-ℚ repository (P₀ has infinite order) closed by us with a comment: a merged pull request by another contributor (#24) proves the same statement and the second clause as well, so ours no longer adds anything; thanks to the author of the map of how the open pull requests line up. Posted on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog. (github.com/elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q, pull request #5). #24 was merged on 2026-11-13; its author had copied us on the map on 2026-11-12. Our pull request had no comment before this one.
Posted, no reply — sent 14 November 2026. A question on our pull request #6 on the ℤ-in-ℚ repository (the frozen target’s statement from eight explicit hypotheses): after #24, five of the eight hypotheses are proved in the main tree, two in a modified form, and one remains a hypothesis in both; ours uses the manuscript’s own templates and definitions; is a statement in the manuscript’s form still useful as a cross-check, or should it be closed. Posted on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog. (github.com/elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q, pull request #6). The pull request stays open for their answer.
Open, no comments — sent 14 November 2026. A public repository holding Declan Gessel’s Lean refutation of Erdős Problem 488, ported from Lean v4.33.0 to v4.35.0 (header only; every proof line byte-identical) and laid out for the Palomar registry, with him as sole author: the statement copied from formal-conjectures with ¬ in front, the build, axioms, six kernels and six refused planted variants recorded in CHECKS.md; a NOTICE that his 50-line adapter stays his with all rights reserved until he licenses it; one issue listing the five points he must confirm (the licence first). Ported and packaged with Claude agents; made public on Carlos’s word. (github.com/carlostoledo1891/erdos-488-lean (issue #1)). Nothing submitted to Palomar. The pod that built and checked it (8 vCPU) cost about US$1.37 and was deleted (404). The sandboxed Comparator, which the registry runs, could not start on the pod; its preflight workflow is in the repository, manual trigger only, not yet run.
Posted, no reply — sent 14 November 2026. The reply to Declan Gessel’s yes on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #5297: the repository is ready for him to look at, public so he needs no invitation, nothing submitted to Palomar; what the port changed and what was checked, made with Claude agents; five points to confirm, the licence of his 50-line adapter first. Posted on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog (its first sentence changed from ‘private, I have invited you’ to ‘public, no invitation needed’ after Carlos chose a public repository). (google-deepmind/formal-conjectures pull request 5297). Follows row gh-fc-5297-palomar-ask-2026-11-13 (answered).
Posted, no reply — sent 13 November 2026. A correction under the review of 2026-11-07 on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #5297 (Erdős #488): the review said the pull request’s CLA check was failing, and that was wrong, cla/google has passed since 2026-09-05; what blocks the pull request is the merge conflict with main (the file’s change of 2026-10-14); since 2026-10-29 a formal_proof link on a solved problem must point to a Palomar entry, and none was found for this proof; the certification is unchanged. First person. Posted on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog. (google-deepmind/formal-conjectures pull request 5297). The error was ours (row gh-fc-5297-review-2026-11-07) and was found on 2026-11-13 while the rebased pull request was prepared; that pull request is HELD on Carlos’s word (prepared locally, nothing sent) until the proof has a Palomar entry or its author answers.
Posted, no reply — sent 13 November 2026. An issue on Ahmed Bou-Rabee’s repository of Kozma–Nitzan results in Lean: Conjecture 1 as printed compared with the sentence his theorem proves, from a statement written independently and sealed first; what was not checked said first (his proof beyond its axioms and two kernels; not a first check, his own restatement exists since 2026-09-05; independence by procedure only); the result (equivalent both ways by proofs that use definitions only, eleven planted variants refused); two observations (the unprinted ‘nonempty’, not on his list of non-literal correspondences and proved immaterial; the encoding against the printed ‘finite graph’); an offer of the bridge files as a pull request. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog. (github.com/nitromannitol/percolation-after-anthropic, issue #1). The repository had no issue before this one. The record: certs/percolation-critical.json (followUps.conjecture1); the page /reports/percolation-critical.html, section 8.
Posted, no reply — sent 13 November 2026. A follow-up comment on our own issue anthropics/formal-math #48: Conjecture 3 ‘verbatim’ under which reading (the finite-graph reading, by proof; letter for letter the statement differs), and continuity of θ on [0, 1] proved for every d ≥ 2 on their library, offered as a pull request; neither a first, the heavy parts theirs; two of our own red controls did not fit their sealed wording, said. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog. (anthropics/formal-math issue 48). The issue had no comment before this one. The page /reports/percolation-critical.html, sections 6 and 7.
Posted, no reply — sent 13 November 2026. One X post for the percolation follow-ups, led by the continuity theorem: Anthropic’s Lean proof gives θ(p_c) = 0 and leaves the textbook form, θ continuous, unclaimed; proved on their library with Claude agents; the hard part theirs. One link, the page; no thread. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d27-percolation-followups-post.txt; posted with tools/x.js on Carlos’s word, the text approved in a dialog; 246 by X’s count.
Public, no reply — sent 13 November 2026. Version 1.2 of the note on critical percolation published on Zenodo: the report printed from the live page (13 pages) and the records, with the three follow-ups of 2026-11-13 (θ continuous on [0, 1] for every d ≥ 2; Kozma–Nitzan’s Conjectures 3 and 1 as printed); the description says first what is added and what is not claimed (no priority; the proofs are the labs’ and the third party’s; the independence on Conjecture 1 is by procedure only). (Zenodo). Concept doi:10.5281/zenodo.24168178; v1.1 was doi:10.5281/zenodo.24175228. Deposited on Carlos’s word (asked in a dialog); the draft’s three files and metadata were read back before publishing, and the published files’ md5 equal the local ones. The archive is the committed corpus at 8f21fe6d with the cert, the recorder and seals/registry.jsonl; unpacked alone, the recorder’s check re-derives the cert.
Posted, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. A reply on the Lean Zulip to an audit post on OpenAI's #378 (ETH) and #003 releases (gilheumpark-bit/ultari-proof-anatomy): the time bound of exact_count_and_sat in SqrtLogSpace/Final.lean (openai/math 7ef5c0cc, byte-identical in our port) holds for every n, the cutoff at line 41 being a case split inside the proof (NativeLargeEntry.run) whose fallback the constants absorb, so the threshold says the speed-up is galactic, not that the theorem is weaker; the Appendix D / Corollary 1.4 gap called real; the eth-chain report linked. Drafted with Claude; posted by Carlos by hand. (Lean Zulip). The link is not recorded: the task was dropped on Carlos's word (2026-11-12). The audit's 2^33,554,431 value for the cutoff was not checked (in our copy it is max 20 (max Nleaf Ns), not printed).
Posted, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. A comment under Gil Kalai's post of 3 September 2026 on Anthropic's Lean proof that there is no percolation at the critical probability, answering its 'we still need to verify if the formalisation is done correctly': θ(p_c) = 0 written by hand from Grimmett as a Lean statement of our own, bridged from Anthropic's proof for every d ≥ 2 and from OpenAI's for d = 3, each checked by two kernels, each bridge failing on a false statement; what it does not settle said in the comment (the informal argument, Kozma–Nitzan's reduction as written, and that the two bridges run on two Lean versions: a careful reading, not a proof); the percolation-critical report linked. Drafted with Claude; posted by Carlos by hand. (Gil Kalai's blog, Combinatorics and more (WordPress)). Read back on the public page the same evening: comment-100346, signed Carlos Toledo, stamped November 12, 2026 at 9:09 pm by the blog's clock, the drafted text word for word. Not on GitHub, so the sweep does not watch it: read the page for replies. Its last caveat (two Lean versions) still stands: the one-Lean port was cut off undecided that evening.
Posted, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. One post: every computer is underneath one tape, one head and a short table of rules; a Turing machine to run and watch, every step explained in plain words, for students, teachers and anyone curious. Linking the page with its light card. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d24-textbook-machine-post.txt (version A); the page /instruments/textbook-machine/. Read back with tools/x.js recent.
Live, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. An issue on Anthropic's formal-math repository: the percolation development at 795efb86 replayed (build, the seven audited theorems on the three standard axioms, their Comparator check with Lean's kernel and nanoda, leanchecker --fresh, two planted statements refused), and a 299-line bridge proving a statement written independently from Grimmett for every d >= 2, accepted by both kernels with that statement as the challenge; planted false statements refused; what it does not show; the question whether 795efb86 will land on main. First person, Claude disclosed. Filed with gh on Carlos's word ("Reveal: everything"). (github.com/anthropics/formal-math, issue #48). plumb reveal-percolation/DRAFTS.md (section 1, paragraphs unwrapped); the page /reports/percolation-critical.html; the note doi:10.5281/zenodo.24168179.
Public, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. The note for the critical-percolation check: the report as a PDF and the records (corpus/percolation-critical, the record and its re-derivation tool), CC BY 4.0. Published on Carlos's word ("Reveal: everything"). (Zenodo). corpus/percolation-critical/note.json; the page prints the DOI.
Posted, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. One post: two AI labs proved in Lean that critical percolation has no infinite cluster; nobody had checked that the Lean says what the textbook says; I wrote the statement from Grimmett's book before reading their proofs, and both proofs prove it. Linking the page with its light card. Sent with tools/x.js on Carlos's word (the approved draft was 326/280 and overclaimed 'every dimension'; this 263-character version approved in a dialog). (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d25-percolation-post.txt; the page /reports/percolation-critical.html.
Live, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. A comment on AdderBoard submission #97 (Skyway1111's 5-parameter hand-coded adder): its claim that every one of the 10^20 pairs is right, checked independently — exact arithmetic by induction over 170,300 cases in two deciders, float32 under a stated libm premise (K <= 32), the margin, three planted variants refuted with replayed witnesses, the fidelity check against its own add(). First person, Claude disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word ("Post as drafted"). (github.com/anadim/AdderBoard, issue #97). the working records are private (plumb adders/, seals 22-23).
Live, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. An issue on Axiom's BGP212: two independent blind readings of its seven analytic hypotheses against the cited statements find the type estimates bounding the all-n discrepancy (sumError) where Stadlmann sums over [x, 2x] (sumErrorDyadic defined, unused), and an added hypothesis x^xi <= M in Bombieri-Vinogradov; asks whether the all-n form is intended. First person, Claude disclosed. Filed with gh on Carlos's word ("Publish readings, file issue"). (github.com/AxiomMath/BGP212, issue #1). corpus/bgp212-readings-2026-11-12 (both readings, pinned); notes/lean-intake-phase2-2026-11-12/ISSUE-BGP212-DRAFT.md.
Live, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. A question on Axiom's BGP212: is the witness F of Gap212Certificate (a symmetric square-integrable F on T_45 with 0 < I(F) < 45·J(F), at the datum gap212Params) published? Not found in the repository at 6641780b nor in PrimeGapsLib at the pinned 1faa7b14, whose PrimeGapsCert/ holds the witnesses for 246 and 600; the datum is not the cited paper's (k = 49), so its numbers do not apply; a request to publish the basis and coefficients or the matrices. Drafted with Claude; filed with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/AxiomMath/BGP212, issue #2). Re-checked the same hour before filing: BGP212 main still 6641780b with one issue (#1, ours, no comment); PrimeGapsLib main = the pin 1faa7b14, PrimeGapsCert/ = Gap246 and Gap600 only. A question, not a finding: nothing is decided about the certificate.
Posted, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. One post: someone prints a number and says it is proven, how would you check; the claim checker put in a web page, the browser redoing the arithmetic exactly and answering in one word, certified, refuted or refused; change the claim and the word turns; no server. Linking the page with its light card. Drafted with Claude; posted from the session with tools/x.js at Carlos's word ("Post version A"). (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d26-claims-page-post.txt (version A; d26b is the one not sent); the page /instruments/textbook-machine/claims/, live the same hour. Read back with tools/x.js recent.
Public, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. Version 1.1 of the critical-percolation note: the report as PDF, reprinted from the updated page, and the records with the evening's amendment — both labs' proofs, both bridges and the statement checked in one Lean (OpenAI's ℤ³ proof ported, its statement file byte-identical), and the statement proved false at d = 1. The first version's caveat about two Lean versions is replaced by that check. Deposited at Carlos's word. (Zenodo). A new version of doi:10.5281/zenodo.24168179 (v1.0, the same day); the concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24168178 resolves to the latest. Three files (README.md, the records archive, the report PDF), their md5 compared with the local files before publishing. corpus/percolation-critical/note.json names v1.1 and keeps v1.0 as earlier.
Posted, no reply — sent 12 November 2026. A reply on a pull request opened against our fork of the ℤ-in-ℚ repository (loning, the two-real-place bridge): thanks; the same four files are upstream as elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q #29, stacked on #6, so merging on the fork would move the head #29 names; the pull request closed in favour of #29, with no judgement of the files, which were not reviewed. Drafted with Claude; posted with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/carlostoledo1891/diophantine-z-q, pull request #1). The pull request had waited four days unanswered; closed after the comment. Upstream #29 was open at the same commit when this was posted and was not touched.
Open, no comments — sent 11 November 2026. A pull request to teorth/optimizationproblems on constants/88a.md (the bounded prime gap constant): one paragraph added to the page's own formalization bullet for OpenAI's 186, with one reference and one contribution note — an outside re-run of the Lean build and of the numerical certificate (builds as shipped; Comparator reproduces and rejects two altered statement files; three kernels; the certificate stops on every released FLINT and passes with flintlib/flint#2790, all 152 integers matching; the 152 quantities recomputed with no shared code), and what stays open (the three axioms remain axioms; integral-to-estimate is argued by hand, not in Lean; no human referee). Not an asterisk removal; no table or README change. First person, Claude disclosed. Filed with gh on Carlos's word ("proceed all"). (github.com/teorth/optimizationproblems, pull request #360). outreach/gh-registry-pr360-88a-2026-11-11.md (untracked); the page /reports/prime-gaps-186.html; the note doi:10.5281/zenodo.24122214; the record certs/prime-gaps-186.json.
Open, no comments — sent 11 November 2026. An issue on flintlib/python-flint: the released wheels (0.9.0 with FLINT 3.6.0, 0.8.0 with FLINT 3.3.1) return a wrong fmpz_poly product in a rare case already fixed on FLINT's main branch (flintlib/flint#2790) and in no release; a three-line witness, the cause, and the statement that nothing needs fixing in python-flint itself. A note for wheel users, not a bug report against FLINT. The witness re-run on both wheels the hour it was filed. First person, Claude disclosed. Filed with gh on Carlos's word ("proceed all"). (github.com/flintlib/python-flint, issue #450). outreach/gh-python-flint-450-2026-11-11.md (untracked); met while replaying the certificate of OpenAI's prime-gap 186 release (/reports/prime-gaps-186.html).
Live, no reply — sent 11 November 2026. A comment on Cameron Freer's evidence pull request in the ℤ-in-ℚ repository: the rows he published in answer to my non-author review were re-checked with a program of my own, written from his README and format file. Each of the 12 decimal tables equals the sum of the squares of its balanced integer rows, coefficient by coefficient (312,874 coefficients, exact integers and exact rationals), the counts are as stated, and seven red controls are caught; his checker was neither read nor run. What stays open is said first. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word ("Send as drafted"). (github.com/elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q, pull request #23). outreach/gh-glazer-pr23-freer-rows-2026-11-11.md (untracked); the record is certs/zq-freer-rows-2026-11-11.json; follows the review of 2026-11-08/09 on #8 and his reply of 2026-11-09
Posted, no reply — sent 11 November 2026. One post: an AI lab ships a Lean proof, what was actually checked? The audit of OpenAI's prime-gap bound of 186, with Claude — the Lean proof valid on 3 assumptions; 152 numbers recomputed with 0 shared code; 2 assumptions hold on 359M cases; proved, none of the 3. Linking the page with its light card. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d23b-prime-gaps-186-post-punch.txt; the page /reports/prime-gaps-186.html. Read back with tools/x.js recent.
Posted, no reply — sent 10 November 2026. A thank-you to arhancanli on teorth/optimizationproblems #221 (merged) for the second replay of the C₃c lower bound: the ratio agrees with the check of 15 October to its thirty printed digits, with three red controls. AI disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/teorth/optimizationproblems/pull/221, a comment). outreach/gh-tp221-thanks-2026-11-09.md (untracked); the credit pinned as arhancanli-c3c-second-replay.
Posted, no reply — sent 10 November 2026. A review comment on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #7678 (Matt Stokes: links to four external Lean proofs — Erdős #902 f_two, #123 powers_2_3, #652 first, #669 k_two): all four hold against the statements here; the kernel accepts each linked theorem as a proof of the declaration's own type at the commit the proofs build against; the four statements read the same on main (three files byte-identical, 123.lean differs by a linter-option line; re-checked the day of posting); standard axioms; Lean, leanchecker, nanoda accept; changed statements refused 4/4, 4/4, 6/6, 8/8; two planted defects per proof file caught. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word ("review and publish the items ready"). (github.com/google-deepmind/formal-conjectures/pull/7678, a comment). outreach/gh-fc7678-review-2026-11-10.md (untracked); records certs/lean-intake-erdos-{902,123,652,669}-claimbox.json; the page /reports/lean-intake.html (the batch table). The PR had one approval (bocowgill, 10-30) and no other comment when posted.
Posted, no reply — sent 10 November 2026. A review comment on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #7660 (Daniel Puri: links to Lean proofs of 22 solved statements): four of the 22 checked, the four that are a single file importing the repository's own module — MathOverflow 75792 complexity_three_pow, the two Agoh–Giuga statements, the square case of s-increasing triples; all four hold at the commit they were built against; standard axioms; Lean, leanchecker, nanoda accept; changed statements refused 6/6, 5/5, 5/5, 4/4; planted defects caught. One finding for the PR: #6762 (14 October) removed answer(True) ↔ from complexity_three_pow, so the linked proof is of the earlier form and no longer matches main; .mp trivial should adapt it (not run). The s-increasing triples first run failed on a defect of our tool, said so in the comment. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word ("review and publish the items ready"). (github.com/google-deepmind/formal-conjectures/pull/7660, a comment). outreach/gh-fc7660-review-2026-11-10.md (untracked); records certs/lean-intake-{mo-75792,giuga-weak,giuga-strong,sqtuples}-claimbox.json; the page /reports/lean-intake.html (the batch table). The other 18 links were not checked. The PR had only the CLA exchange when posted.
Live, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A correction under our cross-tab on the comparator issue: our own 1 GiB-stack runs (October, nanoda 3a240721) were killed by the 16 GB runner on all 15 challenges that reached Comparator, well before the time limit; marleymcwilliams's pass used nanoda d0a02cc5 (31 commits later) in a 13 GB cgroup, so the newer nanoda, not the stack alone, may be what let their nine through; a side-by-side run of both commits announced. AI disclosed. (GitHub, leanprover/lean4 issue #16290). outreach/gh-lean4-16290-correction-2026-11-09.md (untracked); corpus/openai-math/preregistration.json amendment 11; lane-K runs 38048720541, 38051470892, 38074618613. The side-by-side (amendment 18, branch lane-k-nanoda-pin-2026-11-09) is running.
Live, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A non-author COMMENT review (never an approval) of the finite layer of Cameron Freer's conditional quartic stack, posted once on #8 for #8, #9, #11, #12, #13 and #16: every table is what its PR states, passes a necessary sum-of-squares condition, every displayed finite statement holds, the bytes are bound to the PRs; 32 planted changes refused. Gaps first: the quadratic residuals are unpublished, so the sum of squares is not decided; seven of eight tables live only in fork CI artifacts expiring 2027-02-06; upstream CI not run. 'Incomplete review' in the protocol's terms, not the App check; one wording note on #13's retained proof. AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #8 (a review)). outreach/gh-zq-pr8-stack-review-2026-11-08.md (untracked); certs/zq-freer-2026-11-08.json at 78c172bd (sha256 e9a7ee03…); pre-registration a984a568, amendments B a011347b and C a5de5b74 (C accepted 11-09).
Live, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A one-line pointer on #9 to the stack review posted on #8 (this PR's head reviewed; an Incomplete review with no objection to the facts it decides; not the App check). AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #9). outreach/gh-zq-stack-pointers-2026-11-08.md (untracked).
Live, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A one-line pointer on #11 to the stack review posted on #8 (this PR's head reviewed; an Incomplete review with no objection to the facts it decides; not the App check). AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #11). outreach/gh-zq-stack-pointers-2026-11-08.md (untracked).
Live, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A one-line pointer on #12 to the stack review posted on #8 (this PR's head reviewed; an Incomplete review with no objection to the facts it decides; not the App check). AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #12). outreach/gh-zq-stack-pointers-2026-11-08.md (untracked).
Live, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A one-line pointer on #13 to the stack review posted on #8 (this PR's head reviewed; an Incomplete review with no objection to the facts it decides; not the App check). AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #13). outreach/gh-zq-stack-pointers-2026-11-08.md (untracked).
Live, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A one-line pointer on #16 to the stack review posted on #8 (this PR's head reviewed; an Incomplete review with no objection to the facts it decides; not the App check). AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #16). outreach/gh-zq-stack-pointers-2026-11-08.md (untracked).
Posted, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. The amendment-18 side-by-side on leanprover/lean4#16290, as promised in the correction: 15 challenges, nanoda d0a02cc5 vs the 3a240721 control, both 1 GiB in a 13 GiB scope — d0a02cc5 accepts exactly the 9 marleymcwilliams's pass accepts, the control none; so the newer nanoda, not the stack, lets them through. AI disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/leanprover/lean4/issues/16290, a comment). outreach/gh-lean4-16290-result-2026-11-09.md (untracked); record certs/openai-math-kernel.json (amendment18).
Posted, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A review comment on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #5299 (Declan Gessel with GPT-6 Astra: an external Lean refutation of Erdős #786(i)): the proof refutes the statement on main (its own IsMulCardSet and HasDensity unfold to the module's, by the kernel); standard axioms; Lean, leanchecker, nanoda accept; 6 planted wrong statements refused, 4 rewordings accepted, 3 planted defects caught; the PR's diff stale since #6762 (GitHub: conflict); an offer to open a rebased PR only if he wants it. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/google-deepmind/formal-conjectures/pull/5299, a comment). outreach/gh-fc5299-review-2026-11-09.md (untracked); record certs/lean-intake-erdos-786i.json; the page /reports/lean-intake.html#erdos-786. Our rebased PR only on Gessel's yes or ~1 week of silence (~11-16), credit his; the Google CLA still to be signed.
Posted, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. One post on X about the Lean intake: a Lean proof can be correct and still prove the wrong theorem; a check for that, built with Claude; two AI-assisted Erdős refutations, 16/16 planted wrong statements refused, 7/7 planted defects caught; the page's link and its light card. AI disclosed. Posted on Carlos's word (a first copy without the link was deleted and reposted with it). (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d22-lean-intake-post.txt (280/280); the page /reports/lean-intake.html with og-lean-intake.png.
Posted, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A thank-you to arhancanli on teorth/optimizationproblems #275 for reproducing the 84b ceiling to the cell (1399 ≤ Y ≤ 1399.5) with a red control. AI disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/teorth/optimizationproblems/pull/275, a comment). outreach/gh-teorth-275-thanks-2026-11-09.md (untracked); the credit pinned as arhancanli-84b-ceiling-reproduced.
Posted, no reply — sent 9 November 2026. A thank-you on RikiyaT/lm_understand-logs #4 for an outside MATH-500 data point (thinking off under nothink35: 41.2%, 36.2% of answers cut at 8,192 tokens, none of them correct): the thinking-off number depends on the token limit as much as on the model. AI disclosed. Posted with gh on Carlos's word. (github.com/RikiyaT/lm_understand-logs/issues/4, a comment). outreach/gh-lmu-4-thanks-2026-11-09.md (untracked).
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. A comment on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #7706 giving its author the registered Palomar entry PALOMAR-2026-11-08-000001 (verification passed, automated review with no blocking problems) and the formal_proof attribute that replaces the GitHub link and drops the Palomar opt-out. (GitHub, google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #7706). outreach/gh-fc7706-palomar-2026-11-08.md; corpus/heptagon/palomar.json.
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. The verdict on cert-machine issue #3, a claim filed through the public claim form by maximusrufus: CERTIFIED (AlphaEvolve's 26 circles in the unit square, strict; the exact sum 2.63586275641369812 rounds to the printed value); gaps first, the exact numbers, the stock-Python certificate to re-run. (GitHub, carlostoledo1891/cert-machine issue #3). outreach/gh-cert-machine-claim-3-2026-11-08.md; certs/claims-intake-2026-11-08.json.
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. The verdict on cert-machine issue #4, a claim filed through the public claim form by maximusrufus: REFUTED as filed (Q = 0.946897013157…, below 0.9469 by 2.99e-6; the paper's 0.9469 a rounding; C2 ≥ 0.9468 certified); gaps first, the exact numbers, the stock-Python certificate to re-run. (GitHub, carlostoledo1891/cert-machine issue #4). outreach/gh-cert-machine-claim-4-2026-11-08.md; certs/claims-intake-2026-11-08.json.
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. The verdict on cert-machine issue #5, a claim filed through the public claim form by maximusrufus: CERTIFIED at the source's 1e-6 tolerance (strictly 58 pairs overlap, the worst by 3.09e-7; a uniform shrink of 1.547e-7 repairs it); gaps first, the exact numbers, the stock-Python certificate to re-run. (GitHub, carlostoledo1891/cert-machine issue #5). outreach/gh-cert-machine-claim-5-2026-11-08.md; certs/claims-intake-2026-11-08.json.
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. The verdict on cert-machine issue #6, a claim filed through the public claim form by maximusrufus: REFUTED by the pre-registered reading (F(1) = f(1) = 1.0000999… > 1; F = 73.395 outside the sampled range); the printed score agrees and the platform's check, made exhaustive, passes; gaps first, the exact numbers, the stock-Python certificate to re-run. (GitHub, carlostoledo1891/cert-machine issue #6). outreach/gh-cert-machine-claim-6-2026-11-08.md; certs/claims-intake-2026-11-08.json.
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. A reply to arhancanli's independent replay on our C84b pull request: the ceiling value they could not reproduce (0.00071505073…) is the same chain under a looser relaxation in three places, each measured (the constraint on X 5.1·10⁻⁷, the floor 101.9 for ρ 3.7·10⁻⁷, the half-unit cells in Y 2.5·10⁻⁷), which together give their supremum 0.00071392; both are ceilings, theirs the tighter, and 0.000719 stays out of reach either way; AI disclosed. (GitHub, teorth/optimizationproblems PR #275). outreach/gh-optq-275-arhancanli-reply-2026-11-08.md (untracked); the record certs/sumproduct-ledger.json, instruments/sumproduct/c84b.py §4; the three gaps measured in a floating-point model of each step.
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. A short reply to the nanoda maintainer: the stop comes from the module relying on one kernel's implicit let behaviour, not from an error in nanoda; we describe it that way; he may close the issue or keep it as an example of the class; an offer to re-run the export against a change; AI disclosed. (GitHub, ammkrn/nanoda_lib issue #82). outreach/gh-nanoda-82-ammkrn-reply-2026-11-08.md (untracked).
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. The verdict on cert-machine issue #7, a claim filed through the public claim form by maximusrufus: CERTIFIED — ThetaEvolve's zero-tolerance 26 circles (entry 8B-w_RL@65-Formal) pack the unit square with no overlaps, the closest pair about 10⁻¹² apart, the exact sum 2.63598307738811934 rounding to the printed 2.63598308 (the printed figure rounded up, not a lower bound); the stock-Python certificate to re-run. (GitHub, carlostoledo1891/cert-machine issue #7). outreach/gh-cert-machine-claim-7-2026-11-08.md (untracked); certs/claims-intake-7-2026-11-08.json at 8c5f82e5; pre-registered in notes/claims-intake-7-preregistration-2026-11-08.md (b8ed1e1a).
Open, no comments — sent 8 November 2026. The description of our pull request #5 (P₀ has infinite order) rewritten to the maintainer's new PR template (protocol v1.2): gaps first (no non-author review, the protocol check not run, no second kernel, the nine-obligation records not written), every file's SHA-256, the pod checks, the audit-history self-test (exit 0 at main merged in locally), what is not run; the branch left as it is for his 'Update branch'. AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #5 (description edited)). outreach/gh-zq-pr5-update-2026-11-08.md (untracked; the previous text outreach/gh-zq-pr5-infinite-order-2026-11-07.md). Head unchanged (6cf3c1d6); his Research checks still wait for his approval.
Open, no comments — sent 8 November 2026. The description of our pull request #6 (the frozen target from eight hypotheses) rewritten to the maintainer's new PR template: the eight unproved hypotheses and the unreviewed fidelity reading first, file hashes, the statement checks, the 15 planted variants, the self-test (exit 0 at the local merge), two corrections to the earlier text (four of #5's files change, not three; PR #14 links HypCC as a consumer); the branch left as it is. AI disclosed. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #6 (description edited)). outreach/gh-zq-pr6-update-2026-11-08.md (untracked; the previous text outreach/gh-zq-pr6-conditional-2026-11-07.md). Head unchanged (7663a196).
Live, no reply — sent 8 November 2026. A reply under marleymcwilliams's data point on our comparator issue: our run of openai/math at fd4aeeb2 (398 of 416 accepted by both kernels, 18 stopped on resources: 2 nanoda stack overflows, 13 runner terminations, 3 before Comparator) against their results file at 7ef5c0cc — they accept 9 of our 18 including both stack overflows, 9 stopped in both, we accept 2 that hit their memory limit, no kernel rejects anywhere; the case for stack_size_bytes; the commits differ. AI disclosed. (GitHub, leanprover/lean4 issue #16290). outreach/gh-lean4-16290-marley-2026-11-08.md (untracked); certs/openai-math-kernel.json; their pilot/data/comparator-results.json (blob b7c25999) read 2026-11-08.
Live, no reply — sent 7 November 2026. A comment on Francis Zane's 'Lean Replications' thread (replication results and lessons): a second kernel for the OpenAI proof — family-378 with Hawkley's bridge ported into complexitylib's Lean (v4.36.0-rc2), lake comparator with named checkers (Lean's default kernel, leanchecker-paranoid, nanoda, lean4lean) all accepting, con-leche and con-ron accepting on their masters after con-leche#16, both exports archived (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23991348); the step Anthropic's file calls 'not part of the Lean statements or proofs' now in Lean for both labs, each chain ending at ¬ETH on cslib's multitape machine, six checkers on Anthropic's chain (74,801 declarations), a planted statement rejected, complexitylib #2509/#2510 merged; what stays a reading (the note, doi:10.5281/zenodo.23992217); three lessons (a stopped checker is not a rejecting one; the statement from the challenge's own declaration plus a planted change; pin and archive the export bytes); AI disclosed. Posted by Carlos by hand through the blog's form. (ethdiscussion.blog, the 'Lean Replications' post (Francis Zane, 2026-10-30)). outreach/ethdiscussion-lean-replications-2026-11-07.md (untracked); live as comment-41, 2026-11-07 01:31 UTC (the blog prints November 6, 5:31 pm Pacific); the posted text equals the draft word for word (read 2026-11-08 ~03:25 UTC); no reply under it then (Kunal's two later comments are top-level); records certs/eth-openai-chain.json, eth-chain.json
Posted, no reply — sent 7 November 2026. A review (comment) on google-deepmind/formal-conjectures PR #5297, Declan Gessel's Lean refutation of Erdős #488 made with GPT-6 Astra: the independent certification against the entry as it stands today (the statement by type_of%, three planted statements refused; built unchanged on Lean 4.33.0 and 4.33.1; Lean's checker, also from scratch, and nanoda accept; the arithmetic by two deciders; four planted fakes caught), the gaps first, the two maintainer questions answered from the sources (the construction; who was first), and the offer of a rebased PR with the credit Gessel's and GPT-6 Astra's. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted on Carlos's word. (google-deepmind/formal-conjectures pull request 5297). plumb/reveal/review-5297.md (private repo); the record certs/erdos488.json; the page /reports/erdos-488.html; the note doi:10.5281/zenodo.24025464.
Public, no reply — sent 7 November 2026. The note 'An independent certification of the refutation of Erdős Problem #488' (v1.0, 10 pages, CC-BY-4.0) published on Zenodo: Gessel's discovery credited first, the seven pre-registered questions, the deviations from the sealed plan, who found it first as a dated reading, the method as a checklist. (Zenodo). records at cert-machine 0aee5c18; the page /reports/erdos-488.html.
Posted, no reply — sent 7 November 2026. The Erdős #488 thread (4 posts): Gessel with GPT-6 Astra showed in Lean that the share of multiples can more than double; the independent certification against DeepMind's current statement (two kernels, the arithmetic by two programs, four planted fakes caught); what was not checked stated; the discovery credited to Gessel and GPT-6 Astra; links to the note and the report. Posted with tools/x.js on Carlos's word. (X, @_carlos_toledo_ (a thread)). plumb/reveal/x-thread.txt (private repo). The fourth post was replaced twice the same night; it is now 2118888179428151543 (the DOI link, then the report link, no labels), the earlier two deleted.
Live, no reply — sent 7 November 2026. A comment on teorth/optimizationproblems PR #184 (the row [R2026b], He–Tang): C_51 ≥ 0.5850788196744 decided by two implementations sharing no code with each other or with the claimant, the infinite tail included, every planted control as predicted. (GitHub, teorth/optimizationproblems PR #184). outreach/gh-c51-replay-2026-11-07.md; certs/c51-replay.json.
Open, no comments — sent 7 November 2026. A pull request to elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q (invited on issue #3): the Lean lemma that the point P0 has infinite order, with no hypotheses; no file of his edited. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #5). outreach/gh-zq-pr5-infinite-order-2026-11-07.md; certs/zq-pr-build.json. His CI waits on his approval of a first-time contributor.
Open, no comments — sent 7 November 2026. A pull request to elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q, stacked on #5: the frozen target's conclusion, byte for byte, from eight explicit hypotheses (conditional; none of the eight proved), in its own namespace. (GitHub, elliotglazer/diophantine-z-q PR #6). outreach/gh-zq-pr6-conditional-2026-11-07.md; certs/zq-pr-build.json.
Open, no comments — sent 7 November 2026. An issue on wstrinz/spherical-ramsey: the heptagon (the missing half of the README's minimality row) and Theorem A.3 in Lean on the same OpenAI pin as rope AV2; the A.3 route to the phase diagram's non-Ramsey half; nothing asked. (GitHub, wstrinz/spherical-ramsey issue #1). outreach/gh-wstrinz-heptagon-2026-11-07.md.
Open, no comments — sent 7 November 2026. An issue on JD-Jones-ASES/six-concyclic-lean: the heptagon's failure of the criterion, which the README lists as not claimed in Lean, now in Lean, by the argument of the note's certificate 0002; nothing asked. (GitHub, JD-Jones-ASES/six-concyclic-lean issue #1). outreach/gh-jdjones-heptagon-2026-11-07.md.
Open, no comments — sent 7 November 2026. An issue on carlostoledo1891/heptagon-ramsey-lean mentioning Dömötör Pálvölgyi (@domotorp): Theorem A.3 of his appendix, marked unchecked, checked in Lean; one remark, not an error, on Equation (2) for A.3's configuration. (GitHub, carlostoledo1891/heptagon-ramsey-lean issue #1). outreach/gh-heptagon-palvolgyi-2026-11-07.md.
Posted, no reply — sent 7 November 2026. One post: one lab's model wrote a theorem its author marked unchecked; another lab's model proved it in Lean on the first lab's own formalization — Pálvölgyi's heptagon and his Theorem A.3, checked by five kernels; Claude wrote the Lean. Linking the page with its light card. Posted with tools/x.js on Carlos's word. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d20-heptagon-post.txt; the page /reports/heptagon.html.
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. Update comment on leanprover/lean4#16290: con-leche and con-ron fixed upstream (master accepts both OpenAI exports; con-leche#16 closed as completed), nanoda 0.4.17's stack and lean4lean's default fuel unchanged (each accepts with room), the comparator still printing a decline as 'kernel rejected the solution' — the part the issue asks about; the exports' DOI; an offer to open a patch to Lake/CLI/Check.lean. AI help disclosed. Posted on Carlos's word. (GitHub, leanprover/lean4 issue 16290, a comment). the text outreach/gh-lean4-16290-update-2026-11-06.md (untracked); the facts certs/eth-openai-chain.json judge.diagnosis and masters; the deposit doi:10.5281/zenodo.23991348
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. The answer to Mohan Paturi's question ("Do I need to post any new papers in the ETH_Repository?"): one update, the technical note v0.3 (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23992217) superseding v0.2 (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23985003), its one addition (con-leche and con-ron from their master branches accept the OpenAI chain's export; the exports public as doi:10.5281/zenodo.23991348), the stable PDF link that always serves the latest version; nothing else needed. AI help disclosed. Sent by hand from Carlos's mailbox. (e-mail, a reply in the thread of his 2026-11-06 message (answering a received e-mail; the channel rule)). outreach/email-paturi-reply-2026-11-06.md (untracked); companion to email-paturi-eth-repository-v02-2026-11-05. Whether the optional reminder line on the open definition question was added is not recorded here.
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. Both master branches (con-leche dc8ca857, con-ron 97eead2d) overflow their stacks on the 184 MB Track B export that leanchecker --fresh accepts, also on a 128 GB machine and with RUST_MIN_STACK=1 GiB; the bundled v4.35.0 builds stop on fuel at CondZQ.t_body; the commands that rebuild the export (not attached: it holds declarations of an unlicensed repository). First person, Claude disclosed. Filed with gh. (github.com/leanprover/con-leche, a new issue). outreach/gh-con-leche-zq-stack-2026-11-06.md (untracked); certs/zq-trackb.json rows B8.
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. X post, one long post with the art card (design/assets/og-eth-kernels.png): the OpenAI chain's caveat gone — the four bundled checkers had stopped at their limits; two accept with room, con-leche and con-ron accept on their master branches after their maintainer asked; six kernel checkers on the same bytes, about four designs, none ever rejected a declaration; the export public (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23991348); the reading that stays; Claude agents disclosed. Sent by Carlos by hand from the draft notes/x/drops/d16-six-kernels-post.txt. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). the draft notes/x/drops/d16-six-kernels-post.txt (untracked); the facts certs/eth-openai-chain.json masters; the record page /reports/eth-chain.html
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. Reply under Ryan O'Donnell's post (he finished the proof of 'ETH false' in his CMU graduate complexity class, 2026-11-05): for anyone who wants the formal side, both labs' Lean proofs carried to a standard multitape Turing machine in one Lean, six independent kernel checkers accepting OpenAI's; what stays prose (this formal ETH is the textbook one); the page link; the art card as media. First person, Claude agents disclosed in the same sentence. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app (the API refuses replies to posts that do not mention the account). (X, a reply under @BooleanAnalysis (2118377890408456339)). the draft notes/x/drops/d17-odonnell-reply.txt (untracked); the card design/assets/og-eth-kernels.png
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. Reply under Elliot Glazer's ℤ-in-ℚ announcement (2118403066198376903): 'Your main Lean statement was a sorry. Now it's eight named hypotheses: with Claude agents I proved your frozen target from them, kernel-checked, and one premise (P₀ has infinite order) outright. The variable count holds.' with the /z-in-q/ and issue #3 links (the d19 draft, the sharper 'bait' version). Sent by Carlos by hand. (X, a reply under @ElliotGlazer (2118403066198376903)). notes/x/drops/d19-glazer-reply.txt (untracked).
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. The ℤ-in-ℚ thread (5 posts, the card og-z-in-q.png on the first): Version 4's quartic holds up (table, Φ = ΣRᵢ², the 551-step certificate replayed to exactly the residuals); the 11/5 release's counts, tower bounds and 48 Lean modules; the Lean sorry now eight named hypotheses with P₀ proved; the theorem undecided, the source's arithmetic theorem open; links to issue #3 and /z-in-q/. Posted with tools/x.js --send on Carlos's word. (X, @_carlos_toledo_ (a thread)). notes/x/drops/d18-z-in-q-post.txt; posts 2118792342622621735, …344749166617, …346523361522, …348242981072, …349908103633.
Posted, no reply — sent 6 November 2026. The promised run of arhancanli's c89_check.py on our side (quantavane-replays at f4daa1e0): selftest PASS (Franek 2002 reproduced), row sk2026 PASS with the same exact fraction as our 27 October replay, the three red controls as stated, the output identical to their committed result apart from timings. First person, Claude disclosed. Posted on Carlos's word. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 279). outreach/gh-c89check-2026-11-06.md (untracked); the run's output in ~/Projects/replays-ext/out-c89 (outside the repos).
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A last update on anthropics/formal-math#36: Anthropic's eth/ proof ported to complexitylib's Lean (762 of 809 files unchanged, 47 edited, PORT.md), so ethIsFalse and the bridge sit in one environment and give ¬ETH on cslib's multitape machine; Lean's six-checker judge, nanoda and leanchecker --fresh accept; what stays open; the port offered as an upgrade path. Sent on Carlos's word. (GitHub, anthropics/formal-math#36). outreach/gh-formal-math-36-chain.md
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A follow-up on our issue in Daniel Hawkley's RPI map: beyond RPI-ETH-010, Anthropic's ETHIsFalse now reaches cslib's multitape machine in one Lean; the one version gap left is on OpenAI's side; an RPI suggested. Sent on Carlos's word. (GitHub, thinkthoughts/rpi-index#1). outreach/gh-rpi-index-1-chain.md
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A reply in the existing thread with Ramamohan Paturi: Anthropic's proof checked in one Lean through to complexitylib's ETH on cslib's multitape machine; the note (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23966840) and the report; what it does not settle; the target's authors; the definition clause by clause, with one question: does it match ETH as Impagliazzo and Paturi defined it, in particular the (L+1)^e factor. Sent by hand from Carlos's mailbox. (e-mail, a reply in the existing thread (answering a received e-mail; the channel rule)). the text in this session; companion to reports/eth-anthropic-chain.html and paper/eth-chain.pdf
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. One post: Anthropic's AI proof that the Exponential Time Hypothesis is false runs on a machine Anthropic defined; with AI agents, carried to a standard multitape Turing machine in one Lean; six checkers accept, 9 planted fakes fail; the report with the chain card. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d15-anthropic-chain.txt
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. The reply under it: what stays open (the textbook match a reading, OpenAI's one version gap, the same author for proofs and checker; replay it) and the 4-page note with its DOI. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, a reply under @_carlos_toledo_ 2118152759283159493). notes/x/drops/d15-anthropic-chain.txt
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A follow-up for Daniel Hawkley on rpi-index #1: the one version gap named on 5 November is closed — his two bridge theorems and OpenAI's proof ported to complexitylib's Lean beside C2 (3,190 of 3,210 files unchanged, PORT.md), his 27 files vendored under Apache-2.0 with a NOTICE; how it was checked, the judge caveat (four bundled checkers stop; the named re-run), what it does not settle; an offer to change the NOTICE. Sent on Carlos's word. (GitHub, thinkthoughts/rpi-index#1). certs/eth-openai-chain.json; the page /reports/eth-chain.html; the draft outreach/gh-rpi-index-1-openai-chain-2026-11-05.md (untracked)
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. The last update on anthropics/formal-math#36: OpenAI's side in the same Lean as the step to the standard machine — its proof and Hawkley's bridges ported to complexitylib's Lean (3,190 of 3,210 unchanged), ¬ETH on cslib's machine from exact_count_and_sat in one environment; the checks, the judge caveat written out, OpenAI's own challenge file accepting the ported proof; what stays open. Sent on Carlos's word. (GitHub, anthropics/formal-math#36). certs/eth-openai-chain.json; the page /reports/eth-chain.html; the draft outreach/gh-formal-math-36-openai-chain-2026-11-05.md (untracked)
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. X drop d12, a three-post thread with the chain share card: both AI-lab refutations of ETH reach the textbook Turing machine in one Lean each — OpenAI's proof and Hawkley's two bridges ported (3,190 of 3,210 files unchanged); nanoda, leanchecker --fresh, Lean's judge with OpenAI's own challenge file; the caveat (four of six bundled checkers stop at their limits; a re-run with checkers that finish decides); still a reading, still the labs' claims, claimbox claims and cert-machine decides; AI disclosed. Sent on Carlos's word. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). posts 2118392572041212131, 2118392573987348892, 2118392575887368355; media design/assets/og-eth-chain.png; the text notes/x/drops/d12-openai-chain-post.txt (untracked); the page /reports/eth-chain.html
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A one-line reply under arhancanli's independent replay of the K6 certificate on PR #279: it agrees with ours of 27 October to the last digit, the same exact fraction, so the printed bound has two independent second parties with no code in common; I will run their c89_check.py with its controls and say if anything differs. AI help disclosed. Sent on Carlos's word. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 279). the reciprocity scout of arhancanli/quantavane-replays c89/ (f4daa1e0) runs the same evening; its row in corpus/targets.json
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. Issue on leanprover/lean4: lake comparator --paranoid on a 2.45 GB export — leanchecker-paranoid and the default kernel accept, the four bundled external checkers exit non-zero at their own limits (nanoda's worker stack, lean4lean's fuel, con-leche's and con-ron's compiled fuel) and the comparator prints each as 'rejected the solution'; the by-hand reproduction with every number; three asks (report a decline or crash as such; a stack field in the nanoda config; lean4lean's fuel). AI help disclosed. Filed on Carlos's word. (GitHub, leanprover/lean4 issue 16290). the draft outreach/gh-lean4-comparator-limits-2026-11-05.md (untracked); the facts certs/eth-openai-chain.json judge.shipped / judge.diagnosis
Live, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A reply under our comment-24 on the 'announce your results' page: both labs' Lean proofs reach the standard multitape machine inside one Lean each — Anthropic's eth/ ported (762 of 809 unchanged) and, through the bridge, ¬ETH on cslib's machine; OpenAI's proof with Hawkley's two bridge theorems ported (3,190 of 3,210 unchanged), OpenAI's own Comparator challenge file accepting the ported proof; the checks, the caveat on the judge's checker list on OpenAI's side; what stays a reading; the report and the note v0.2 (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23985003); AI disclosed. Posted by Carlos by hand through the blog's form. (ethdiscussion.blog, the 'announce your results' page, a reply to #comment-24). outreach/ethdiscussion-reply-openai-chain-2026-11-05.md (untracked); live as comment-34 within the hour (read 2026-11-05 ~18:30 UTC); records certs/eth-openai-chain.json, eth-chain.json
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A reply under Ryan Williams's 'announce your new results related to not-ETH here' post: both proofs now reach the standard multitape machine inside one Lean each (Anthropic's eth/ 762/809 unchanged, OpenAI's with Hawkley's two bridges 3,190/3,210), every step checked, the caveats written out; with Claude agents; the report link. First person, AI disclosed. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~18:12 UTC, from the drafts of this session. (X, a reply under Ryan Williams's 'announce your results' post (rrwilliams, 2116987964123168822)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the ETH conversation (five targets ranked by fit; the news-aggregator and crypto-confusion posts skipped); the page /reports/eth-chain.html
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A reply under KostyaAI's 'the statement-match question is now open twice': the machine-model half of the statement-match question has a Lean answer: both labs' statements imply ¬ETH on cslib's multitape machine, proofs ported and checked in one Lean; the textbook reading stays a reading; with Claude agents; the report link. First person, AI disclosed. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~18:12 UTC, from the drafts of this session. (X, a reply under KostyaAI's post on the statement-match question (2115892976916250798)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the ETH conversation (five targets ranked by fit; the news-aggregator and crypto-confusion posts skipped); the page /reports/eth-chain.html
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A reply under 99sunny2's 'Nanoda still overflows at 128M / 512M / 2G' (their openai/math audit): the bundled nanoda_bin 0.4.17 ignores stack_size_bytes and overflows; nanoda_lib built from source at 8de7e0c4 with 16 threads and a 1 GiB stack accepts all 101,621 declarations in 142 s; nanoda_lib#80 filed; the report link. First person, AI disclosed. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~18:12 UTC, from the drafts of this session. (X, a reply under 99sunny2's post on their nanoda overflow (2116516703878459412)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the ETH conversation (five targets ranked by fit; the news-aggregator and crypto-confusion posts skipped); the page /reports/eth-chain.html
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A reply under zkbernard12138's independent rebuild of OpenAI's proof (3,977 modules, three standard axioms): the same on the kernel side and one step further: OpenAI's proof plus Hawkley's two bridges ported to complexitylib's Lean, reaching ¬ETH on cslib's multitape machine in one environment; nanoda needs a 1 GiB stack on that export; with Claude agents; the report link. First person, AI disclosed. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~18:12 UTC, from the drafts of this session. (X, a reply under zkbernard12138's independent rebuild post (2117892107062886804)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the ETH conversation (five targets ranked by fit; the news-aggregator and crypto-confusion posts skipped); the page /reports/eth-chain.html
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. A reply under jrdothoughts's 'here's the part worth following' thread: each proof is stated on a machine its own lab defined; both now carry over to the textbook Turing machine in Lean, every step checked, the one remaining reading named; with Claude agents; the report link. First person, AI disclosed. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~18:12 UTC, from the drafts of this session. (X, a reply under jrdothoughts's thread (2115905386020540576)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the ETH conversation (five targets ranked by fit; the news-aggregator and crypto-confusion posts skipped); the page /reports/eth-chain.html
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. The Verify Seal post: seal the draft before it goes into a model — a salted digest leaves the machine, two public anchors date it, one file revealable later; 24 forged seals, 0 accepted; the page link; the art card as media. First person, AI disclosed where the work is named. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~20:00 UTC, from this session's drafts. (X, @_carlos_toledo_, a standalone post with the art card). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the Math 2.0 and AI-scientist conversation (searches on scooping, priority and OpenTimestamps found nothing current); the page /reports/verify-seal.html; the card design/assets/og-verify-seal.png
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. the talk's quiet line (people hold back directions for fear of being scooped through a model) has a small answer: seal the draft first; with Claude agents; the page link. First person, AI disclosed where the work is named. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~20:00 UTC, from this session's drafts. (X, a reply under Jose A. Alonso's 'Math 2.0 — Terence Tao' post (2117587991623614844)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the Math 2.0 and AI-scientist conversation (searches on scooping, priority and OpenTimestamps found nothing current); the page /reports/verify-seal.html; the card design/assets/og-verify-seal.png
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. when the count is dead, dates matter: a seal proves possession of exact bytes by a date and reveals nothing until chosen; free, anchored in Bitcoin and a public git commit; the page link. First person, AI disclosed where the work is named. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~20:00 UTC, from this session's drafts. (X, a reply under psantacl's '722 math papers in one morning, the count is dead' (2118376449786757348)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the Math 2.0 and AI-scientist conversation (searches on scooping, priority and OpenTimestamps found nothing current); the page /reports/verify-seal.html; the card design/assets/og-verify-seal.png
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. one thing the AI scientist needs that nobody is building: a way for a human to prove they held a draft before it went into the model; the page link. First person, AI disclosed where the work is named. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~20:00 UTC, from this session's drafts. (X, a reply under the Chen Institute's AIAS+ 2026 post (2118129348830199915)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the Math 2.0 and AI-scientist conversation (searches on scooping, priority and OpenTimestamps found nothing current); the page /reports/verify-seal.html; the card design/assets/og-verify-seal.png
Posted, no reply — sent 5 November 2026. the same text as the Jose A. Alonso reply; the page link. First person, AI disclosed where the work is named. Sent by Carlos by hand from the X app on 2026-11-05 ~20:00 UTC, from this session's drafts. (X, a reply under Bahram Shakerin's Math 2.0 share (2117676132573274297)). the scout: node tools/x.js search on the Math 2.0 and AI-scientist conversation (searches on scooping, priority and OpenTimestamps found nothing current); the page /reports/verify-seal.html; the card design/assets/og-verify-seal.png
Posted, no reply — sent 4 November 2026. The one-post reply under Grigore Roșu's thread on using several models as a review team: what cross-model review misses is right proofs of narrower statements (34 of 242 in OpenAI's math release, passed by every model and kernel), with claimbox named as an early, open attempt at that gap. Posted by Carlos by hand from the X app. (X, a reply under @RosuGrigore's post 2117763822370935037). notes/x/reply-rosu-2026-11-04.txt; the /claimbox/ page has no og:image (a card rendered for the claimbox project in outreach/claimbox-og/).
Live, no reply — sent 4 November 2026. A reply under our comment-24 on the 'announce your results' page: C2, Anthropic's ETHIsFalse implies ETH fails on cslib's standard multitape machine with a binary encoding; with Hawkley's chain both labs' statements reach it; the version seams and the textbook reading stated as open; Zhuang's and complexitylib's native re-proofs named. Posted by Carlos by hand through the blog's form. (ethdiscussion.blog, the 'announce your results' page, a reply to #comment-24). outreach/ethdiscussion-reply-c2-2026-11-04.md; records certs/eth-c2.json, eth-c1.json, eth-cslib-d1.json; live as comment-30 (shown November 4, 12:30 pm site time; read 2026-11-05 ~18:30 UTC)
Posted, no reply — sent 4 November 2026. A follow-up on anthropics/formal-math#36: the step from FinTM2 on encClauses to a standard machine, named as informal in our earlier comment, is now in Lean (EthBridge.Anthropic.not_eth_of_ethIsFalse, claimbox 235fbfa); how it was checked; what it does not settle; the disclosure. (GitHub, anthropics/formal-math#36). outreach/gh-formal-math-36-c2.md, sent on Carlos's word
Posted, no reply — sent 4 November 2026. One post: the objection to both AI proofs that the Exponential Time Hypothesis is false (each runs on its lab's own machine), that step now in Lean to a standard multitape Turing machine, two kernels each; the textbook match still a reading; the /eth/ chain card. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d14-eth-standard-post.txt (posted from the earlier wording)
Posted, no reply — sent 4 November 2026. A follow-up reply in the thread on the ETH constant: the machine-model step now in Lean to a standard multitape Turing machine, two kernels; what stays a reading marked. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, a reply under @DimitrisPapail's post 2115451187801514168). notes/x/reply-eth-amplifiers-2026-11-04.txt, text A
Posted, no reply — sent 4 November 2026. A follow-up reply in the thread linking the organizers' announce page: the machine-model step now in Lean to a standard multitape Turing machine. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, a reply under @rrwilliams's post 2116987964123168822). notes/x/reply-eth-amplifiers-2026-11-04.txt, text A
Posted, no reply — sent 4 November 2026. One post in Portuguese tagging @antihypebr and @fastcompanybra, which covered the ETH claims: the machine step closed in Lean with AI agents, the proofs reaching a standard Turing machine, from Brazil. Posted by Carlos by hand. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). outreach/brasil-eth-comments-2026-11-04.md
Posted, visibility unconfirmed — sent 4 November 2026. A comment in Portuguese under ANTI/HYPE's article on OpenAI's ETH claim, answering the point it left open: both Lean proofs re-checked with two kernels; the machine step closed in Lean with AI agents, Anthropic's statement reaching a standard multitape Turing machine and OpenAI's through Hawkley's bridge; the textbook match and the Lean version gaps marked as readings. Posted by Carlos by hand. (antihype.com.br, comments under 'OpenAI diz que IA derrubou a Hipótese do Tempo Exponencial'). outreach/brasil-eth-comments-2026-11-04.md, C1; 2026-11-12: the article’s header counts 1 comment (it counted 0 when this one was written). The comment’s text and author load in the browser from the site’s own service and were not read, so whose comment it is stays unconfirmed.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. One reply under the authors' main X post (Takehi, 2117313742891327994): thanks for the release; the edit real as described; the pre-registered re-run — their settings 7.2%, the untouched model under Qwen's non-thinking settings 44–52%; the page linked. Posted BY HAND from @_carlos_toledo_ after the GitHub issue existed. (x.com, reply to rikiyatakehi/status/2117313742891327994). notes/x/reply-wsp-one-2026-11-03.txt (the one-reply version; the four-post chain kept for our own thread). The standalone X post d12 and the ETH post d13 follow the next morning.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The standalone X post on the Weight-Space Programming verification: the edit real; the untouched model under Qwen's own settings 44–52% against the post's 48.1; the 6× mostly settings; the bar-chart card (three arms from the records) attached; the page linked. Posted BY HAND from @_carlos_toledo_. (x.com, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d12-wsp-post.txt + d12-wsp.png (cards-src/cards-wsp-baseline.js). The link carries ?v=2 so X fetched the page's own card (og-wsp.png) rather than its cached landing card.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The reply to Daniel Hawkley's contact-form e-mail (formalize.now) on his ETH bridge RPI-378.3d: the light theorem CERTIFIED on a GitHub runner, the heavy link CERTIFIED on a pod (build, axioms, nanoda with its negative control, leanchecker --fresh), the gaps first (the predicate vs OpenAI's checked statement; the version seam read, not decided), and an offer to measure the seam in his direction. Sent by hand from Carlos's mailbox. (e-mail (answering a received e-mail; the channel rule)). outreach/hawkley-reply-2026-11-03.md; records certs/eth-hawkley-bridge.json, certs/eth-hawkley-heavy.json; his row on /eth/ beside TSavo's. If he accepts the seam offer: pre-register, then the export-and-compare of certs/eth-seam.json in his direction (a GitHub run).
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The standalone X post on the ETH bridges: two labs claim ETH is false in two machine models; a third party's Lean bridge from OpenAI's statement to Anthropic's replayed with two kernels and a fresh replay, OpenAI's proof included; one seam stays open. Posted from the session with tools/x.js at Carlos's word ("Send d13"). (x.com, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d13-eth-bridge-post.txt; the link carries ?v=2 so X fetches /eth/'s own card (og-eth.png) rather than the landing card cached from the 11-02 post.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. A reply under Giulio Prisco's Metafuturing week post (the column that cited the ETH replay): thanks, and the two updates since — the third-party bridges replayed and certified (/eth/), MIT's weight edit re-run under the model's own settings. Posted by hand from @_carlos_toledo_. (x.com, reply to giulioprisco/status/2116444605491097973). notes/x/reply-prisco-2026-11-03.txt; the column is pinned as recognition row metafuturing-eth-column.
Live, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The announcement on Mohan Paturi's 'announce your results' page (the organizers' channel; Ryan Williams linked it on X 11-01): three verification results — both formalizations replayed with two kernels and leanchecker; the textbook ETH written once in Lean and refuted by each lab's statement in its own model (51 theorems); the two third-party bridges across the machine-model step (TSavo's, Hawkley's two halves) replayed and certified, the version seam measured and stated as read, not decided. In the format asked: name, affiliation, no coauthors, the disclosures, the link. (ethdiscussion.blog, the 'announce your results' page (comments)). outreach/ethdiscussion-announce-2026-11-03.md; posted by hand, shown as 9:04 am site time on 11-03, comment #24. The e-mail to rpaturi@ucsd.edu SENT 11-03 (row email-paturi-eth-repository-2026-11-03); the one-line reply under Williams's post (notes/x/reply-rrwilliams-2026-11-03.txt) is Carlos's to send.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. One reply under Ryan Williams's 'announce your new results' post, pointing to the announcement on the organizers' page: both formalizations replayed with two kernels, the textbook ETH written once in Lean and refuted by each statement in its own model, the two third-party bridges replayed and certified. Posted by hand from @_carlos_toledo_. (x.com, reply to rrwilliams/status/2116987964123168822). notes/x/reply-rrwilliams-2026-11-03.txt; companion to ethdiscussion-announce-2026-11-03 and email-paturi-eth-repository-2026-11-03.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The replay of TSavo's ETH bridge told to its author: CERTIFIED by Comparator with Lean's kernel and nanoda on a GitHub runner, the lakefile amendment the run had to declare, and the version seam measured term by term (the statement the same kernel term up to a binder name; 308 of 2,689 reachable constants differ between the two Mathlibs); Hawkley's bridge the other way round mentioned. (TSavo/eth-bridge issue 1). outreach/tsavo-issue-2026-11-03.md; records certs/eth-tsavo-bridge.json, certs/eth-seam.json. Posted from the session with gh at Carlos's word.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. A public flag for Daniel Hawkley on his registry, in its own format (third-party report vs local reproduction): both edges replayed and CERTIFIED — RPI-ETH-010 on a GitHub runner (Comparator with Lean's kernel and nanoda), RPI-ETH-008 on a CPU pod (build, axioms, nanoda with its negative control, leanchecker --fresh); the records to attach; the machine-model reading and the seam offer; in case the e-mail of 11-03 did not arrive. (thinkthoughts/rpi-index issue 1). outreach/hawkley-issue-2026-11-03.md; companion to email-hawkley-reply-2026-11-03 (thinkthoughts/math has issues off). Posted from the session with gh at Carlos's word.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The two-line follow-up to Reg Saddler (@zaibatsu, The Build) under his ETH column: the third party's bridge the other way round replayed with two kernels (it holds), and MIT's weight-space programming re-run under Qwen's own settings; an offer to walk him through either. Posted by Carlos by hand from the X app. (X, a reply under Saddler's column (conversation 2115840407095439365)). notes/x/reply-zaibatsu-2026-11-03.txt; posted 14:51 UTC; the first reply (11-02, 2117396073526227039) answered his correction. His column is recognition row the-build-eth-column.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The three-post reply under the critic's post on MIT's Weight-Space Programming (@dummerspast39, 1,520 likes, 162k impressions; pinned in corpus/wsp/critic-2117416640132366570.json): most of his numbers hold against the released bytes (93.1% cut, 7.2% under their settings; 45.6% / 51.7% with no edit under Qwen's settings, his 47 inside; 2 tensors; Frogger/Freeway, 876, 20× PPO, two games lost, sycophancy), two refuted ('test answers' — 3,680 practice answers; 'one run replayed' — 1,024 sampled episodes), the termination reading. Posted by Carlos by hand from the X app. (X, three replies under the critic's post, each a reply to the previous (conversation 2117416640132366570)). notes/x/reply-critic-2026-11-03.txt + .md; posted 22:41–22:42 UTC (2117748912534499369, 2117748973574529300, 2117749238050513045).
Public, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. A public compute ask: two posts tagging @PrimeIntellect with the Verify Gym chart (seven open models below exact bisection, every number from certs/verify-gym-scorecard.json) asking compute for one pre-registered training run (Qwen3.5-9B, GRPO, US$500 cap, the stopping rule, a tolerance-reward twin; published on the Hub whichever way it falls). Posted by tools/x.js on Carlos's word. (X, a two-post thread from @_carlos_toledo_). the X thread with the Verify Gym chart; the second post 2117753359729844651; posted 22:58 UTC.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The one-post reply under Pawel Huryn's post on the Weights story (82 likes): the same reading from the bytes, the baseline under Qwen's own settings (45.6% / 51.7%), the dose tuned on 3,680 practice answers, the records link. Posted by Carlos by hand from the X app. (X, a reply under @PawelHuryn's post 2117639929463197885). notes/x/reply-huryn-2026-11-03.txt; posted 23:01 UTC by Carlos.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The one-post reply under @rryssf's loop-fix thread: the direction is reversed, not subtracted (W − 6·u(uᵀW), the 6 to three decimals), and the gain is termination (35 of 500 → all right; 303 → 241), the records link. Posted by Carlos by hand from the X app. (X, a reply under @rryssf's post 2117523275266101287). notes/x/reply-rryssf-2026-11-03.txt; posted 23:01 UTC by Carlos.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The one-post reply to @miriamgonp's 'compared to what?': the untouched model under Qwen's own settings (45.6% / 51.7%) against the edit's 48.1; pre-registered, exact grading, texts released; the edit real, the 6× mostly a settings effect. Posted by Carlos by hand from the X app. (X, a reply under @miriamgonp's post 2117686029507309778). notes/x/reply-miriamgonp-2026-11-03.txt; posted 23:02 UTC by Carlos.
Posted, no reply — sent 3 November 2026. The one-post reply under Runchu Tian's steering critique (42 likes): steering, with the direction reversed, not deleted (the 6 to three decimals), and the gain termination; the records link. Posted by Carlos by hand from the X app. (X, a reply under @Runchu_Tian's post 2117633356464902492). notes/x/reply-runchu-2026-11-03.txt; posted by Carlos 11-03 (Carlos confirmed; posted ~23:10 UTC).
Open, no comments — sent 3 November 2026. The issue on Jason Davies's repository telling him his classification of the minimum universal sets of MacMahon cubes was replayed and certified twice here with no shared code — the 300 released witnesses re-built with our own geometry, the ten theorems through Lean's kernel and nanoda with our own axiom report — with the two records, the statement reading, what is not claimed, and the page. Posted with gh on Carlos's word. (jasondavies/macmahon-min-universal-sets, an issue). outreach/davies-issue-2026-11-03.md; the page carlostoledo.co/reports/macmahon.html went live minutes before; posted ~23:45 UTC.
Posted, no reply — sent 2 November 2026. One post with an image: AI now publishes faster than anyone can check; one release held 719 manuscripts, and 131 claims are decided here exactly, each with a certificate that re-runs without Carlos’s code; that is Verify; the /verify/ page linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d08-verify-post.txt with d08-verify.png; posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 2 November 2026. One reply to Reg Saddler (@zaibatsu) under his ETH column: thanks for the careful column and the correction; the bridge has since grown to 51 theorems, each checked by two kernels; his closing question stands, the two textbook steps are still prose in both labs’ work and in Carlos’s, and a formalization of them would be replayed. (X, @_carlos_toledo_, a reply under Reg Saddler’s ETH column (conversation 2115840407095439365)). notes/x/reply-zaibatsu-2026-11-02.txt; posted by hand by Carlos. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts. Its one counted reply is Carlos’s own follow-up of 2026-11-03 (row x-zaibatsu-followup-2026-11-03), which replies to this post.
Posted, no reply — sent 31 October 2026. One post with an image: 9.75 quadrillion pairs of points, each decided exactly, in 17 machine-hours, nine of them on dimension 45, where the claimant’s own check had skipped the pairs; the kissing report linked; “my tools are built with Claude” in the post. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d03-kissing-hours-post.txt; posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 31 October 2026. One post with an image: on the kissing-number ladder in dimension 11 every AI bound is now certified, and the one still undecided is the human one, Ganzhinov’s 592 from 2022, whose bytes are next; the kissing report linked; “my tools are built with Claude” in the post. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/drops/d06-human-bound-post.txt; posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 31 October 2026. One post with an image: most charts draw a fitted curve and a measured point with the same solid line; in these the stroke says what each number rests on (solid decided, dashed computed, dotted chosen, nothing where it was refused); the /grammar/ page linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/07-grammar-post.txt; posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 31 October 2026. One reply: agreed that the checker should not be a model; Verify decides AI claims with exact arithmetic and a second proof kernel, offline; the gap is the statement, since in OpenAI’s math release 34 of 242 formal statements prove less than their headline; the /verify page linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_, a reply under a post by @wyatt_benno (conversation 2116532090128752776)). notes/x/reply-wyatt-benno-2026-10-31.txt; posted by hand by Carlos. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 30 October 2026. One post on X: both claimed ETH refutations pass two independent kernels and a fresh replay; each statement refutes a textbook ETH written in Lean; whether that Lean ETH is the textbook one is read, not decided; the /eth/ link, with the disclosures (tools built with Claude; one claim is Anthropic’s). (X, a reply under Dimitris Papailiopoulos’ post on the galactic ETH constant). posted by hand from @_carlos_toledo_ (the API refuses replies to posts that do not mention the account); the post replied to is @DimitrisPapail’s, status 2115451187801514168; the reply’s own id, 2116018520253456482, was read back on 2026-11-12.
Posted, no reply — sent 30 October 2026. A reply to maximusrufus's fixes for our C_16 replay observations (maximusrufus/c16-bgw-certificates@0c57070): the certifier scripts now in the repository; both float fields checked exactly as the nearest doubles on the correct side of their rationals; the rationals byte-identical to those replayed, so the verdicts stand (lower certified, upper finite core certified with analytic steps read); the asterisks left to the maintainers. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 246). outreach/c16-246-followup-2026-10-30.md; the check never ran the claimant's code.
Live, no reply — sent 29 October 2026. TSavo’s Lean bridge (OpenAI’s Claim → MainResults.ETHIsFalse, TSavo/eth-bridge @ 34f9ca20) replayed and certified by two kernels, with its two gaps named (the README’s lakefile cannot run Comparator; the two Lean versions compose by the source text, not one kernel run); and their question answered, whether MainResults means ETH: two independent readings say ETHIsFalse is literally s₃ = 0, and our generic Lean ETH equals Anthropic’s s by rfl. (anthropics/formal-math issue 36). certs/eth-tsavo-bridge.json (run 40789891989), certs/eth-bridge.json, the readings; /eth/ linked; disclosures included
Live, no reply — sent 29 October 2026. A follow-up offering the model-generic ETH (ETHBridge/Generic.lean, MIT) as a fixed target for later claims: ETH and #ETH stated once, ¬ETH and ¬#ETH proved from each lab’s statement in its own model (Anthropic’s #ETH on the formulas MainTheorem speaks of), 51 theorems each accepted by Lean’s kernel at build, Lean’s kernel in Comparator and nanoda; and the join’s version seam measured: the statement is the same kernel term up to a binder name, but ℝ’s arithmetic differs between Mathlib 0df444a3 and d13f23b7, so no single kernel has checked the two statements are one proposition. (anthropics/formal-math issue 36). certs/eth-bridge.json (run 40947192141), certs/eth-seam.json (run 40947568989); disclosures included; v2, with the seam paragraph
Posted, no reply — sent 29 October 2026. A three-post thread opening the account: AI systems announce records, constants and proofs faster than anyone reads them, so each claim is re-decided from its published bytes in exact arithmetic without the claimant’s code, with three possible answers (CERTIFIED, REFUTED, REFUSED); 131 machine-generated claims decided since August and ten asterisks off the optimization-constants registry in four merged pull requests; every page built from records that re-run, nothing peer-reviewed; the site linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/01-pinned-intro.txt; three posts (2115627840267841889, 2115627842687860828, 2115627844847968723), posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 29 October 2026. One post with a link reply: an absolute-tolerance grader admitted 3,582 of 4,000 provably wrong answers (89.55%) in a test mix minted from certificates, while a certificate grader admits none and rejects nothing right; the measurement page linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/02-tolerance-grader.txt and notes/x/02-link-reply.txt; the link reply (2115631450250678505) points to /reports/envs.html; posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 29 October 2026. One post with a video and a link reply: in the Campos Basin, 32 years of daily wave maxima and five certified fits fan out past the end of the data and are 3.19 m apart at 1,000 years; every fit is certified and the choice of family is what moves the number; the return-level map linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/09-campos-tail.txt and notes/x/09-link-reply.txt; the link reply (2115636337558622446) points to /instruments/return-level-atlas/map/; posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 29 October 2026. One post with a link reply: the Qiushi Engine claimed 19 new kissing-number lower bounds; at Carlos’s request the authors published the missing point sets, every pair (9.75 × 10^15 of them) was decided exactly, all 19 hold, and their README credits the check; the kissing report linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/03-kissing.txt and notes/x/03-link-reply.txt; the link reply (2115640000310067648) points to /reports/kissing.html; posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Posted, no reply — sent 29 October 2026. A four-post thread: OpenAI and Anthropic each published a Lean proof that the Exponential Time Hypothesis is false; both replayed with two independent kernels and both check against their own statements; the textbook ETH written once in Lean and each statement proved to refute it in its lab’s own machine model; moving between machine models stays informal, a third party’s bridge replayed; the disclosure that the tools are built with Claude and one of the two claims is Anthropic’s; the /eth/ page linked. (X, @_carlos_toledo_). notes/x/04-eth-thread.txt and notes/x/04-link-reply.txt; four posts (2115640133357564329, 2115640134976590026, 2115640138604720561, and the link reply 2115640174491144320 to /eth/); posted with tools/x.js. Read back on 2026-11-12 with the account’s own posts.
Filed, no reply — sent 28 October 2026. Answers to the TCS community form on the two claimed refutations of ETH (organizers Impagliazzo, Paturi, Williams): how to organize the examination (proof checks, statement readings, the informal mathematics kept apart), making the argument accessible, the consequences in three registers, and a virtual meeting (yes; two two-hour sessions). It reports both Lean proofs checked by two kernels, the two readings, and the Lean bridge (one textbook ETH, each lab’s statement proved to refute it in its own model), with the disclosures: tools and proofs written with Claude, one claim is Anthropic’s, no affiliation with either lab. (the TCS Community Feedback about ETH form (Google Forms; responses reviewed by the organizers, not public)). submitted 2026-10-28 ~23:20 UTC; links /eth/ (unlisted), certs/eth-kernel.json, corpus/eth-refutation/bridge/; the answers as sent are kept locally in notes/tcs-form-answers-2026-10-28.md (the optional blog comment was not posted)
Live, no reply — sent 28 October 2026. A short comment for readers checking the formal side of the two ETH claims: both Lean developments replayed with Comparator under Lean’s kernel and nanoda (both check against their own statements, standard axioms only); OpenAI’s Lean defines no ETH, so the textbook ETH written once in Lean and each statement proved to refute it in its own lab’s machine model, the step between machine models informal for both; with the disclosures (tools and proofs written with Claude, one claim is Anthropic’s, no affiliation with either lab). (ethdiscussion.blog, the organizers’ public discussion page (comments moderated)). posted 2026-10-28 ~23:30 UTC; links /eth/ (unlisted); the text as sent is in notes/tcs-form-answers-2026-10-28.md (local). Check whether it appears; then set the status to live, no reply.
Posted, no reply — sent 27 October 2026. The K5 Ramsey-multiplicity certificate (C₈₉b ≤ 0.0016870052, J. SK's 192-block step graphon) re-derived by two implementations sharing no code with each other or with the claimant's evaluators: the density equals the fraction the page states, the printed bound is it rounded up; five controls — offered as the second party the registry's rule of 2026-10-26 asks for. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 277). certs/graphon-replay.json at d813a99b; the page /reports/optconst-queue.html#graphons; the claimant is the second party on our #249, so this is the reciprocal confirmation; a README nit noted (1,248 pairs moved, not all 18,528 entries)
Posted, no reply — sent 27 October 2026. maximusrufus's C₁₆ enclosure (2.1562247706 ≤ C₁₆ ≤ 2.1562256466) re-decided from the published certificates by two implementations sharing no code, the claimant's checkers read as text and never run: the lower end holds exactly; every finite step of the upper end holds on all 84 boxes against the printed digits (the boxes support 2.1562256458), its analytic steps read and re-derived — offered as the second party the registry's rule asks for, and as the reciprocal check of their reruns of ours. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 246). certs/c16-replay.json at f4ee2715; /reports/optconst-queue.html#c16; four observations noted (the bound the boxes support, the checkers' tolerance, the unpublished certifiers, two float slips)
Posted, no reply — sent 27 October 2026. The K4 Ramsey-multiplicity certificate (C₈₉ ≤ 0.0301388794, J. SK's 3,840-block step graphon) re-derived by two implementations sharing no code (a C kernel on a rented CPU pod, every block; an exact JavaScript second implementation by orbits) agreeing on all 3,840 blocks: the density is the fraction the page states, the printed bound it rounded up; offered as the second party. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 255). certs/graphon-k4.json at f4ee2715; /reports/optconst-queue.html#graphon-k4; the README nit noted ([Kos2026] shown as C₈₉'s best, not the page's smaller [SK2026])
Posted, no reply — sent 27 October 2026. J. SK's R(3,33) ≥ 241 circulant certificate (Zenodo 23552014, linked from the C₁₇b page) re-decided with our own code: the graph rebuilt from the printed connection set, triangle-free, and no independent 33-set by an orbital branch-and-bound (one root by transitivity, 31 stabilizer orbits, 9 minutes on 8 threads); a SAT second path closed 22 of the 31 cubes with checked proofs. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 252). certs/ramsey-ledger.json (the outside row) at f4ee2715; /reports/ramsey-graphs.html#other-graphs
Filed, no reply — sent 26 October 2026. C₈₄b: the chain's ceiling printed rounded up (0.0007150508) instead of truncated (0.0007150507), a one-digit follow-up to #257 (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 275). the digit from certs/sumproduct-ledger.json (d5e86354)
Filed, no reply — sent 23 October 2026. zeta23 (anthropics/formal-math), the ξ′ side: the quartic window 8.85·10⁻⁷ below its own family's optimum; the degree-6 window v₆ and D1trunc 15 give 0.86864150 / 0.93432075 against the formalization's 0.86864017 / 0.93432008 (+1.33·10⁻⁶), with the optimality certificate over even polynomial windows of degree ≤ 20, the ζ calibration to eighteen digits, what AtOne.lean needs, and the abstract's 0.8362 as a truncation (anthropics/formal-math issue 30). a separate matter from the law-file thread (#8); every number a decision on claimbox afd776c's certificates and re-derived by the paper's generator (a third implementation); the e-mail to the paper's authors was dropped (e-mails off), its content here; 2026-10-23 a follow-up comment linked the companion paper now live (https://github.com/anthropics/formal-math/issues/30#issuecomment-6357042052)
Posted, no reply — sent 23 October 2026. the reply to Leandre Jack's e-mail of 2026-10-21 asking for the C₃₁ replay: both rows replayed and holding, the h = 9 and h = 10 numbers, the observation on his λ (1.5·10⁻¹¹ and 1.1·10⁻⁷ above ours), PR #249, the page, two questions (his state order; a Zenodo deposit of our vectors) (e-mail, a reply to his). sent by Carlos Toledo by hand; the one e-mail the channel rule allows — an answer to one received
Filed, no reply — sent 23 October 2026. google-deepmind/cryptids: the finite layer re-checked at 664cd039 from the bytes by two implementations sharing no code with verify.py (143 of 152 checks hold) and both comparator configurations passed under Lean’s kernel and nanoda; six notes — the riemann_104 check never runs riemann_120 (we ran it 89,775,610 steps: no halt), the checkpoint table’s steps are the 179th/210th/879th/1,721st root entries (the selection rule unpublished), “non-halting transitions” counted two ways (785/759 vs 784/758 cells), proof-file digests recorded and compared to nothing, statements checked by substring, three smaller prints (google-deepmind/cryptids issue 14). their CONTRIBUTING invites oversights as issues; items 1–3 re-run independently before posting; text in outreach/github-2026-10-23.md; no PR offered (it would need Google’s CLA)
Posted, no reply — sent 22 October 2026. zeta23 (anthropics/formal-math): the bandwidth-one ceiling's row certificate re-decided from LawN256.lean's 256 integers by two programs sharing no code with Lean (three claims hold; the CUE containment 124/131); the request for the law file cert_N256_blk_b128m.json behind EnclOK joined (anthropics/formal-math issue 8, comment). a comment on the open request of 2026-08-12 (issues #8 and #14 already asked; no author reply in two months), not a new issue; evidence at claimbox b37d980; the companion paper (riemann-finite-layer) waits on the XiPrime pins before its push
Filed, no reply — sent 20 October 2026. AlphaProof Nexus: every published Erdős proof and the corrected #741(i) replayed under Comparator against formal-conjectures' statements and two kernels (all hold), with four notes on the OEIS results: A382590's statement counts prime factors with multiplicity and is degenerate; earlier proofs on record for A325046, A382590 and A237271; A237271 defined by an already-proved characterization; 38 of 44 OEIS proofs published. (google-deepmind/alphaproof-nexus-results issue 4). filed on request; evidence at cert-machine 7b13a32f
Open, no comments — sent 15 October 2026. The finite core of the Bandeira 0.2(a) disproof re-decided with our own certificate (it holds), and the two gaps at its declared boundary named. (Oxelra-AI/Bandeira-0.2a-open-source issue 1 (two posts)).
Live, no reply — sent 15 October 2026. Both constructions for C1a and C1b re-decided exactly; the bounds hold. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 225). The pull request was merged on 2026-10-18 and the maintainer then marked both bounds with the asterisk, as replayed only by the submitting team's own checker (commit 3010f7ed); the comment is not cited.
Live, no reply — sent 15 October 2026. The C3c lower bound decided with interval entropies at 128 bits; it holds. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 221). Merged on 2026-10-18 with its asterisk kept; the replay was then offered as pull request 230 the same day, decided a second time by an implementation sharing no code with the first.
Live, no reply — sent 15 October 2026. A record package for the de Bruijn–Newman constant read file by file: what an outside party can and cannot decide from it. (teorth/optimizationproblems pull request 210). Merged on 2026-10-18 with its asterisk, and every row of the constant since 2021 now carries one as not independently replayed — consistent with the comment's reading; the comment itself has no reply.
Open, no comments — sent 6 October 2026. The diagonal-Ramsey certificate of Appendix A.3 refuted: its λ = 1 pair lies outside the region Theorem 14 requires, and the validator accepts it by taking a min where membership needs both inequalities. (ewang26/HorizonMath issue 10). The awesome-ai-proofs registry keeps its entry "disputed" until this thread has a comment from the authors.
Closed, no comment — sent 6 October 2026. K(18) ≥ 8,358 checked exactly from the published data, and the dimensions 25–31 with it. (alexlegeartis/KissingNumbers issue 2). closed by the owner as completed on 2026-10-23, without a comment; no commit to the repository since 2026-09-27
Open, no comments — sent 6 October 2026. K(25) ≥ 197,058 checked exactly; in dimension 31 the stored added points differ from the README. (k-nic/Leech_lifting issue 1).
Open, no comments — sent 6 October 2026. One table row needs an update: the circles-in-a-rectangle solution (n = 21), read exactly, has 44 overlapping pairs and is rejected by today's verifier. (togethercomputer/EinsteinArena-new-SOTA issue 14).
Live, no reply — sent 6 October 2026. The 600-step Erdős construction re-decided in exact arithmetic, in a thread asking whether the published score can be verified. (test-time-training/discover issue 19). The thread had been closed since July; the comment answers its question.
Open, no comments — sent 6 October 2026. δ₃ = 117/2192 claimed optimal for k = 3 of Erdős #1186, and why the exact value of the published δ₄ blocks the next step. (incrediblecrab/erdos-1186 issue 1). 2026-10-23: the repository incrediblecrab/erdos-1186 no longer exists (404), so the issue is gone with it
Open, no comments — sent 6 October 2026. Remark 17's iteration checked against Theorem 14 on all of (0, 1] in interval arithmetic: it holds, given the paper. (snorin239/RamseyLean issue 1).
Open, no comments — sent 6 October 2026. The hot spots conjecture (Rauch, 1974) proposed for formalization, with a certified family of trapezoids. (google-deepmind/formal-conjectures issue 6874).
Live, no reply — sent 6 October 2026. The Hankel-determinant method measured past ζ(5) by a separate engine: it does not reach ζ(7). (mo271/Zeta5 issue 3).
Open, no comments — sent 5 October 2026. The Time Horizon 1.1 logistic fits re-derived in standard-library Python, each optimum certified by Krawczyk's method instead of refitted. (METR/eval-analysis-public issue 43).
Open, no comments — sent 5 October 2026. The 604-point kissing configuration in dimension 11 certified in exact arithmetic and congruent to the EinsteinArena one; two more configurations decided. (dualverse-ai/station_data_v2 issue 2 (two posts)).
Open, no comments — sent 5 October 2026. The counterexample library decided case by case, and the one case whose verdict depends on its reading (feasible Picard steps for DPP likelihood). (suvrit/count-ex-machina issue 1).
Live, no reply — sent 5 October 2026. A third-party report on Anand's ζ(7) preprint confirmed with exact values: I_out in Table 5 does not follow from (59). (gmDevi/zeta-7-21-lean issue 1).
Public, no reply — sent 5 October 2026. A partial proof claim for Erdős #1186: δ₃ = 117/2192 for three-term progressions, with an exact lower-bound certificate. (the proof claims of erdosproblems.com/1186). Accepted by the moderators and shown on the problem from 2026-10-06; no comment on it by 2026-10-17. On 2026-11-12 the thread still shows Comments (0) and Proof claims (1). The forum froze new problem comments and proof claims on 2026-10-06, the day this claim appeared.
Open, no comments — sent 16 September 2026. Erdős #1 made effective: the explicit sets and their certificates, offered to the project tracking the problem. (tadamcz/erdos1 issue 2).
Public, no reply — sent 16 September 2026. Erdős #1 made effective: explicit sets for which the conjecture's bound fails at stated sizes, with the certificates. (the erdosproblems.com forum, thread 1). Visible (dated 14:25 on 16 Sep 2026). One post came after it, building on the thread's earlier suggestion rather than answering this one.
Live, no reply — sent 3 September 2026. Both ends of Erdős #1038: per-degree theorems on the supremum side, then a certified lower bound inf ≥ 1.828 with no tail estimate and no assumed minimizer. (teorth/erdosproblems issue 179 (three comments)). The second comment was edited after posting to fix rendering: GitHub's KaTeX rejects \\operatorname and renders \\, as a visible comma. A third comment (2026-10-06) corrected our own figure on #1038; nobody has answered any of the three.
Public, no reply — sent 3 September 2026. The same infimum result, rewritten for the forum's own rules — derivations pushed to the linked PDF because the site forbids posting partial proofs in full. (the erdosproblems.com forum, thread 1038). Visible on the thread (dated 14:39 on 3 Sep 2026) and still its last post on 2026-10-17.
Public, no reply — sent 26 August 2026. A correction to a GPT-published constant on Erdős #852 — refuted at its 11th significant digit (its 12th decimal place), certified replacement attached. (the problem's discussion thread on erdosproblems.com). It cleared moderation and stands visible (the thread dates it 00:06 on 26 Aug 2026, and it is still the last post there). The thread as it stands is pinned in this repository as evidence bytes. Visible is not endorsed: nobody has answered it, no author has amended anything, and clearing a moderation queue is not peer review and not an independent rerun.
Public, no reply — sent 26 August 2026. The certified table of λ(n) for Chowla's cosine problem (#510), with the λ(4) result. (the erdosproblems.com forum). Visible on the thread since it was posted (dated 21:32 on 26 Aug 2026); it was first seen there on 2026-10-06, because the watch had been reading the problem page, where comments do not render. Still the last post on 2026-10-17. On 2026-11-12 it is still the newest of the thread’s three comments. The forum froze new problem comments and proof claims on 2026-10-06 (the site’s post “Changes”), so the λ(4) follow-up prepared for this thread has not been posted.
Filed, no reply — sent 5 August 2026. An independent confirmation of the computational appendix of a claimed proof of Erdős #1038 — all 30 printed decimals verified by a different route, Krawczyk rather than bisection. (Pengbinghui/pipeline-math issue 5, the claiming authors' own repository). To my knowledge still the only independent verification of any part of any of the three claimed proofs of that problem.
Posted, no reply — sent 4 August 2026. An evaluation note on a public automated-alignment sandbox whose authors invited stress-testing. (safety-research/automated-w2s-research issue 2).
Still in the moderation queue — sent 4 August 2026. A note on Erdős #290 for the problem’s forum thread, about the constant whose decimal expansion was prepared as an OEIS entry (the entry itself was not submitted). (the erdosproblems.com forum, thread 290). Never became visible. Not on erdosproblems.com/forum/thread/290 on 2026-10-17 (five posts, none of them this one), nor on 2026-11-12, 100 days after it was submitted: the same five comments, the newest dated 24 Sep 2026. The forum froze new problem comments on 2026-10-06, so it is not expected to appear. The same mathematics is public on teorth/erdosproblems issue 164 (row gh-164).
Status words mean exactly what they say and nothing more: public, no reply — visible to everyone, answered by nobody · filed, no reply — received by the other party's tracker, unanswered · posted, no reply — published where it was aimed, unanswered · open, no comments — an issue nobody has responded to · live, no reply — a comment visible in the thread, unanswered · posted, visibility unconfirmed — submitted, and we have not verified it appeared · submitted, awaiting moderation — in a queue, not yet visible · still in the moderation queue — submitted and confirmed not yet visible · answered — the other party replied in the thread; what came back is in the note · reviewed, not merged — a reviewer who is not a maintainer answered in the review; nothing merged · merged — accepted into the other party's repository · closed, no comment — the other party closed it without a reply. Last checked 8 November 2026.
Filed is not accepted; posted is not replied. Third parties have re-derived results on this site eight times (above): six with code of their own, sharing none with ours, and two with the tools that wrote the record; none of it has been peer-reviewed. That is the plain state of it, and it is why the pages ship their own falsifiers rather than asking for trust.
Traffic in the other direction has somewhere to go now: the claims desk takes a claim and answers it in public, whichever way it falls. 145 claims have been decided so far, and five were sent by somebody else.
working together
What a collaboration or a hiring process can check
Open to collaboration — an independent audit of a release or a registry, a benchmark review, a certified decision product for an operation with a number to defend — and to roles in evaluation and verification. The four artifacts below were built to be re-run rather than read; every number in them is taken from a ledger at build time, and a number that stops holding refuses this page. The conventional CV is available on request.
METR’s time horizon, re-derived as certificates. 44 of 44 fits with the optimum proved unique in a box below 10⁻¹⁰ on METR’s own files; the printed coefficients are the box’s rounding for 22 of 23 models; the post-2023 doubling time re-derives as 128.740 days against the printed 128.744. The page.
blind-spot, an RTL mutation task under Inspect and verifiers. 400 pooled mutants, 892 submissions scored three ways with 0 disagreements; 3 frontier models, 180 rollouts, every one re-scored offline with 0 disagreements. The instrument · the Inspect task.
GSM8K’s answer key, re-decided. 4,282 test and 23,716 train calculator annotations evaluated from the expressions they print; 2 test and 24 train keys print a step that does not hold as printed. The page.
Three verifier-graded environments on the Prime Intellect hub.blind-spot, break-the-grader and lattice-claims, no answer key in any of them: a kill is simulated, a lattice claim is decided exactly, a grader is broken or is not. At its last control build (git 7d776bd0) the repository ran 242 batteries, 242 of them green. break-the-grader · the repository.
decided
exact arithmetic backs it
computed
float, or a number someone printed; nothing decided it
why these numbers stand as they do
computed — the doubling time METR printed; nothing here decided it
absent by choice
What this page does not contain
No employment history, no degrees, no years-of-experience figure, no self-rated skills. Each of those is a claim a reader would have to take on trust, and putting them beside claims that can be re-run devalues the second kind. If a process needs a conventional CV, ask and you will get one.
method
How these pages are made, since it bears on how fast they appear
The mathematics, the design of every check, and the decision about what may be claimed are mine. The writing and much of the implementation are done with AI assistance, under the discipline this site describes: a screen may only prune, a gate counts only once it has been shown to go red on a broken copy, and every page recomputes its numbers from the records at build time — a build that drifts refuses to ship. The output rate is a consequence of that arrangement, and saying so seems better than letting a reader wonder.
The code and the checks on it share one author, so they rule out slips but not a shared misconception. An independent recomputation of any result here — in whatever you already trust — is the thing this site most wants, and a refutation gets published like any other result, with the name of whoever found it if they want it there.
contact
One address, for everything
carlos@carlostoledo.co — corrections, questions about a step, collaboration, hiring. A message that names the page and the one step it doubts can be answered properly; a general introduction usually cannot. For a hiring process, the section above is the checkable half of a CV; the conventional one on request.