cert-machine · aerospace front · every verdict re-proved at this build

eVTOL energy reserves: feasibility certificates under the FAA rule

The reserve, provable: energy-feasibility certificates for eVTOL missions

Battery-electric air taxis fly under a hard reserve rule — the FAA's powered-lift SFAR (14 CFR Part 194, 89 FR 92296 (2024-11-21, eff. 2025-01-21)) allows a VFR reserve of 20 minutes at normal cruise only where the flight manual shows a vertical landing is possible along the whole route, and 30 minutes by day otherwise — and industry is arguing the number because reserves gate route economics. Every feasibility figure in that argument today is simulation. This page holds the other kind of statement: for a mission whose durations, powers, capacity and efficiency are known only as BOXES, the verdict "every parameter point lands at or above the reserve floor" is decided — CERTIFIED, REFUTED with an exact falsifying witness, or honestly REFUSED — by interval arithmetic with outward rounding. Mathematically certified enclosures; no airworthiness meaning, and the page says so.

tl;dr
  • The finding. A provable energy-feasibility envelope for an eVTOL mission class: under representative boxes, the mathematically certified endurance frontier sits at 18 min 41 s of cruise under the 20-minute reserve and 11 min 21 s under the 30-minute one — every probe of that frontier a certified verdict, not a Monte Carlo percentile. The ten extra minutes of reserve cost 7 min 20 s of certified cruise, to the second.
  • The mechanism. Used and reserve energy are enclosed over the whole parameter box (outward-rounded interval arithmetic); the universal verdict needs one one-sided comparison each way. A refutation re-proves the most favorable corner in exact BigInt rationals — if even that corner fails, all points do — and a box that straddles the floor is REFUSED, never averaged. The battery checks the interval bounds against all 256 corners of three instances in exact rationals and fires 4 red controls per run. What every verdict rests on, and how far each premise was checked, is §2.
  • Check it. node instruments/evtol/battery.js from a clone — 25 checks, 4 of them red controls; the mission table below was certified during this page's build.
certified endurance, 20-min reserve
18 min 41 s cruise
the longest cruise (the low end of a two-minute cruise box) whose mission CERTIFIES for every parameter point in the boxes — found by bisection with a certified verdict at every probe
certified endurance, 30-min reserve
11 min 21 s cruise
the same frontier under 30 minutes, the same rule's day tier when that condition is not shown — the ten extra minutes cost 7 min 20 s of certified cruise
verdicts
3, all exercised
CERTIFIED / REFUTED-with-witness / REFUSED — the mission ladder below shows each, live
witness arithmetic
BigInt rationals
every refutation carries its most-favorable corner re-proved exactly; the calibration instance's margin is matched exactly in rationals (40 kWh)
battery
25 checks · 4 reds
interval bounds checked against 256-corner exact sweeps; forged inputs must be refused at the door
what this is not
no airworthiness claim
"certified" here is a mathematical statement about boxes and arithmetic — never a regulatory status
§0 · the frontier

Where proof ends, and what sits in the gap

The same mission, decided at every cruise duration under each rule. Both strip boundaries are located to the second by bisection, with a certified verdict on each side; a sweep every 15 seconds checks that the verdict only ever moves from CERTIFIED to REFUSED to REFUTED as the cruise grows, and the build refuses the page if it does not.

0 min 10 min 20 min 30 min 40 min 50 min 60 min 20-min reserve frontier 18 min 41 s 30-min reserve frontier 11 min 21 s cruise duration of the mission, the low end of its two-minute box (hover-climb and hover-land held fixed) CERTIFIED REFUSED (undecidable) REFUTED
Under the 20-minute reserve the mission certifies out to 18 min 41 s of cruise; a 30-minute reserve pulls that back to 11 min 21 s — 7 min 20 s of certified cruise is what the extra ten minutes of reserve cost, to the second. The hatched band between CERTIFIED and REFUTED is the honest one: there the stated boxes straddle the rule and the instrument refuses rather than guessing, and its width is a measurement of the boxes, not of an aircraft.
§1 · the rule and the gap

A named regulatory number, defended by simulation

The FAA's 2024 powered-lift SFAR sets energy reserves for eVTOL operations — under VFR, 20 minutes at normal cruise where the flight manual shows a vertical landing is possible along the whole route, otherwise 30 minutes by day and 45 by night (the rule pack apps/skyaudit/scenario/rules/faa-sfar-vfr.json, pinned to the Federal Register text) — and the industry pushback is public and quantitative: reserves determine which routes close. EASA sets a 5-minute final reserve inside a wider energy plan that does not reduce to one number (apps/skyaudit/scenario/rules/easa-final-reserve.json). Yet every number in that argument — mission feasibility, deconfliction energy overhead, reserve adequacy — is produced by simulation: Monte Carlo percentiles over sampled parameters, floating-point optimizers, no statement that survives an adversarial reading of "for every case in the stated envelope".

The gap is not modeling sophistication — the field's power models are fine. The gap is the QUANTIFIER. "Feasible in 10,000 samples" and "feasible for every point in the box" are different claims, and only the second is the shape a reserve rule actually asserts. Interval arithmetic decides the second shape directly. We have not found such a certificate in the eVTOL energy literature; no search record is pinned here, so that is a statement about our reading, not a survey.

§2 · the instrument

Three verdicts, one honest refusal

A mission is segments (hover-climb, cruise, hover-land, …) with duration and electrical-power BOXES; the battery contributes usable-energy and efficiency boxes; the reserve rule contributes a reserve time at a reserve power. Used and required energy are enclosed over the whole box with outward rounding, and the universal verdict follows from two one-sided comparisons: worst case clears — CERTIFIED for every point; best case fails — REFUTED for every point, with the most favorable corner re-proved negative in exact BigInt rationals as the falsifying witness; anything between — REFUSED, with both margins printed. A refusal means the boxes genuinely contain passing and failing aircraft, and no honest instrument can say more until the boxes tighten.

The corner-witness logic is checked, not assumed: the battery sweeps all 256 corners of three two-segment instances (feasible, marginal, doomed) in exact rationals and requires the interval bounds to be sound AND corner-achieving (tight to rounding) on each. Scope, honestly: this is energy accounting — Σ duration·power/efficiency against usable capacity — not electrochemistry. Voltage sag, temperature and aging live INSIDE the boxes a user states, which is exactly why the inputs are boxes: widen them to cover what the model does not resolve, and every verdict above stays sound.

Every verdict is exact about the boxes it was given. What it says about an aircraft rests on premises the arithmetic cannot reach. In the order a verdict travels through them, each with the rung its checking reached — validated (against the thing itself, held out), compared (against a model that keeps more), verified (the code against an exact solution of its own equations) or assumed (adopted; nothing here checked it):

  1. assumed
    The mission and the aircraft, as boxes hover 420–520 kW for 60–90 s each way, cruise 110–150 kW, usable 130–145 kWh, efficiency 0.88–0.94, reserve power 90–110 kW: a representative vectored-thrust class chosen for this page, not any maker's published numbers, typed in tools/build-report-evtol-energy.js. Nothing here measured an aircraft.
  2. assumed
    Energy as bookkeeping used energy is Σ duration × power / efficiency against usable capacity. No voltage sag, temperature or ageing: they are meant to sit inside the boxes, and whether these boxes are wide enough to hold them is not measured here.
  3. assumed
    The reserve rule 20 minutes from the SFAR rule pack (14 CFR Part 194, 89 FR 92296 (2024-11-21, eff. 2025-01-21)), which grants it only where a vertical landing is possible along the whole route; 30 minutes is the same rule's day tier otherwise. Whether a route qualifies is not decided here. The rule asks for those minutes at normal cruising speed; this page holds them at a reserve power of 90–110 kW, at or below its own cruise box of 110–150 kW — a chosen reading of "normal cruise", not the rule's number.
  4. verified
    The arithmetic the interval bounds are checked against all 256 corners of three instances in exact rationals, sound and tight on each; the calibration instance's margin is exactly 40 kWh in rationals; every refutation is re-proved at its best corner in BigInt rationals (instruments/evtol/battery.js, 25 checks, run at this build). The last step, usable − used − reserve, is a round-to-nearest subtraction, so the build refuses any verdict on this page whose margin is within 1e−9 kWh of zero.

The arithmetic is verified; the weakest premise is assumed. A verdict here is exact given the boxes and the rule: about a real aircraft it says what those boxes say, and no more.

§3 · the mission ladder

Certified live at this build, under both reserve rules

mission20-min reservemargin (kWh)30-min reservemargin (kWh)
short hop (10 min cruise)CERTIFIED27.5CERTIFIED6.7
design mission (20 min cruise)REFUSED-0.9 … 61.2REFUSED-21.8 … 45.2
stretch (35 min cruise)REFUSED-43.5 … 31.9REFUSED-64.4 … 16.0
deep stretch (55 min cruise)REFUTED-7.1REFUTED-23.0

Margins are worst-case for CERTIFIED rows, best-case for REFUTED rows, and the worst…best pair for REFUSED rows — the two numbers a refusal honestly has — each printed rounded outward, a worst case down and a best case up. The parameter boxes are a representative vectored-thrust class (hover 420–520 kW, cruise 110–150 kW, usable 130–145 kWh, efficiency 0.88–0.94, reserve power 90–110 kW), stated in the page source as inputs — they are NOT any manufacturer's aircraft, and tightening or widening them re-decides every row by the same arithmetic.

§4 · the frontier

Where the certified envelope ends

Bisecting on cruise duration with a certified verdict at every probe puts the end of the mathematically certified envelope at 18 min 41 s of cruise under the 20-minute reserve and 11 min 21 s under the 30-minute one, for the stated boxes; each is the low end of a two-minute cruise box, so the cruise it certifies runs up to two minutes longer. That difference — 7 min 20 s of provable endurance — is the quantity the reserve debate is actually about, computed here as a theorem about the boxes rather than a fleet average. The same bisection run against an operator's own measured boxes is the instrument's intended use.

§5 · where this went

The aerospace front, opened

This was the first instrument of this site's aerospace front: the cheapest object where a certified universal statement replaces a simulation percentile in a live regulatory argument. The same verdict was then run on a real day: SkyAudit re-flies a pinned day of New York helicopter traffic with four eVTOLs' own published boxes under the same SFAR rule pack, and the glide band draws an engine-out reach as a proved inner ring, a refuted outer one and the undecided annulus between.

contact

Write to Carlos

Sent by Web3Forms to Carlos’s inbox; nothing stored here.

Or write to carlos@carlostoledo.co, or open the public pilot form on GitHub.